NSW coroner examines role of unregistered birth keeper after infant death
A New South Wales inquest is investigating whether advice from a self-described birth keeper was appropriate after a baby born at home died en route to a hospital.
The coroner’s court in Lismore heard evidence that a self-described birth keeper told a pregnant woman to "go home and rest" after medical professionals urged her to seek emergency care. The woman, who distrusted hospitals, had been advised that her baby was severely compromised at 43 weeks and that an urgent hospital visit was necessary. Instead, she contacted the birth keeper, who responded, "she was quite upset and anxious. I advised her to go home and rest. Calm yourself down and consider what you want to do."
The baby, identified as Baby R, was delivered outdoors by the father at 9:51 a.m., with two doulas present who lacked formal medical training. The infant did not latch onto the breast, and 14 hours later an ambulance was called. The umbilical cord and placenta remained attached, and the child died while being transferred to a helicopter at 12:22 a.m. The cause of death was recorded as unascertained, though a neonatologist suggested hypoxic-ischemic encephalopathy linked to severe post-maturity.
Prof. Hannah Dahlen, a midwifery academic, testified that a qualified midwife would have monitored the birth closely, noting that the distinction between a doula and a birthing midwife lies in the theoretical knowledge that enables interpretation of signs, symptoms, and pathology. Counsel assisting Ragni Mathur told the court that women are turning to unregulated free birthing because of "traumatic or coercive experiences, fragmented care, lack of trust in clinicians, lack of available clinicians, lack of services in regional NSW, and including child protection notifications and regulatory actions against new lives".
The inquest will assess whether the care provided before, during, and after the birth was reasonable given the circumstances and whether the involvement of an unregistered support worker was appropriate.