NSW inquest finds lack of medical checks may have cost four babies their lives
Just the facts

NSW inquest finds lack of medical checks may have cost four babies their lives

Summary

A coronial inquest in New South Wales concluded that routine prenatal scans and hospital delivery could have prevented the deaths of four infants who were born in free-birth or home-birth settings between 2022 and 2024.

A coronial inquest in Lismore heard that four infants who died in New South Wales after free-birth or home-birth deliveries might have survived with routine medical monitoring. The babies – identified as DH, D, R and B – died in the state’s northern rivers region between 2022 and 2024.

Witnesses said the mothers chose non-medical births because of previous traumatic experiences, distrust of clinicians and limited access to services. Baby DH died about eight hours after a free birth attended only by a doula. Neonatologist Nicholas Evans testified that the baby’s complex heart abnormalities would have been detected in a standard pregnancy scan and that the lack of hospital birth “meant that he didn’t have a chance.”

In the case of Baby D, the mother was unaware she was carrying twins. Experts said the infant likely died from respiratory distress linked to an undiagnosed heart condition, and that early detection of the twin pregnancy could have prompted close monitoring and timely medical intervention.

Baby R was born at 43 weeks and one day in a free-birth setting. Evans noted that standard practice is to induce labour or perform a caesarean section by 42 weeks, and that a miscalculated due date contributed to the baby’s death. An ultrasound on 19 August indicated a medical emergency, but the birth keeper advised the mother to remain at home.

Baby B’s mother declined hospital delivery for her twins despite repeated warnings. The infant likely died from group B streptococcus infection, pneumonia and sepsis, conditions that are often treatable with antibiotics in a hospital setting. The twin survived after receiving medical care.

The inquest, which is ongoing, highlighted the importance of routine prenatal scans, timely hospital delivery and access to emergency medical care for high-risk pregnancies.

Keep reading — for free

Create a free account to follow the news. No card required.