Mamdani, Cuomo, and Sliwa Engage in Heated Final NYC Mayoral Debate
In the final New York City mayoral debate, candidates Zohran Mamdani, Andrew Cuomo, and Curtis Sliwa exchanged sharp critiques on issues including housing, public safety, and immigration, highlighting their contrasting visions for the city's future.
In the final New York City mayoral debate held on October 22, 2025, Democratic nominee Zohran Mamdani, independent candidate Andrew Cuomo, and Republican Curtis Sliwa engaged in a contentious exchange, addressing key issues such as housing, public safety, and immigration.
Mamdani criticized both opponents for focusing on each other's campaigns rather than presenting new ideas. Cuomo accused Mamdani of lacking originality, stating he "has no new ideas" and is merely reiterating past policies. Mamdani countered, emphasizing his forward-looking plans and accusing his opponents of instilling fear.
On immigration, Cuomo advocated for limiting federal immigration agents' focus on minor offenses, suggesting such matters should be handled by local police. Sliwa proposed negotiating with federal authorities to secure favorable terms for the city. Mamdani criticized Cuomo's approach, labeling him "Donald Trump's puppet."
The candidates also addressed the city's homelessness crisis, with Mamdani proposing to expand programs that connect shelter families with city workers. Cuomo highlighted the increase in homelessness since his tenure as governor, though he did not provide specific figures. Sliwa interjected, referencing Cuomo's resignation amid impeachment proceedings.
Regarding housing, Mamdani advocated for a rent freeze and the construction of affordable housing units. Cuomo defended previous rent increases as necessary and questioned the feasibility of Mamdani's proposals, noting the mayor's limited control over the city's rent guidelines board. Mamdani responded by emphasizing the mayor's authority to appoint board members.
The debate also touched on Mamdani's stance toward Jewish New Yorkers. Cuomo cited a letter from 650 rabbis expressing concern over Mamdani's positions, accusing him of fueling anti-Semitism. Sliwa went further, alleging Mamdani supports "global jihad." Mamdani denied these allegations, reaffirming his commitment to the safety and dignity of all communities.
As the debate progressed, tensions escalated between Cuomo and Mamdani, with both candidates questioning each other's experience and leadership capabilities. Sliwa criticized both, likening their exchanges to schoolyard fights and questioning their qualifications.
The candidates also discussed the future of Rikers Island, with Mamdani supporting its closure by 2027, calling it a "stain on the history" of New York. Cuomo and Sliwa opposed the closure, citing concerns over public safety.
On economic issues, Mamdani proposed a phased increase to a $30 minimum wage, arguing that New York is becoming unaffordable for working-class residents. Sliwa dismissed the proposal as unrealistic.
The debate concluded without a clear consensus, leaving voters to decide among the candidates' differing visions for New York City's future. Election Day is scheduled for November 4, with early voting beginning on October 25.
Source
The GuardianFact-checking
Fact-check the facts of the article using external sources and databases.