Neanderthal Shanidar A Shows Evidence of Both Care and Violence, Study Finds
Juste les faits

Neanderthal Shanidar A Shows Evidence of Both Care and Violence, Study Finds

Résumé

Analysis of a 75,000-year-old Neanderthal skeleton from Iraq reveals healed facial injuries and a fatal spear wound, highlighting complex social behavior.

Archaeologists have identified a combination of healed facial trauma and a lethal spear wound on the remains of Shanidar A, a Neanderthal who lived about 75,000 years ago in what is now Iraqi Kurdistan. The study, published in Scientific Reports, examined a fragmented but well-preserved skeleton that included teeth, ribs, a hand and a scapula with a round 15-millimetre perforation likely caused by a wooden spear. Researchers concluded that the facial injuries occurred while the individual was alive and healed, whereas the shoulder-blade wound was fatal.

"What is particularly remarkable is that we see evidence of two contrasting facets of human nature—care and violence—juxtaposed in the same individual," said Emma Pomeroy, a bioanthropologist at the University of Cambridge and lead author of the paper.

Co-author Graeme Barker noted that past interpretations of Neanderthals have swung between portraying them as savage and as peaceful, describing both extremes as overly simplistic. He added that the findings illustrate that Neanderthals, like modern humans, possessed capacities for both assistance and aggression.

The Shanidar Cave site, which contains five Neanderthal burials, has long been central to debates over prehistoric burial practices. Shanidar A, estimated to be about 45 years old at death, was interred behind a large rock pillar, suggesting intentional treatment of the dead. Earlier excavations had suggested burial with flowers based on pollen analysis, a claim now considered unlikely.

The research team evaluated alternative explanations for the scapular hole, such as animal activity or post-burial damage, and compared it with known spear-induced injuries in humans and other animals. Barker concluded that the evidence points to death by spear thrust, though the exact circumstances—whether intra-group conflict, inter-group violence, or encounter with Homo sapiens—remain speculative.

Pomeroy highlighted that healed injuries are common in Neanderthal fossils, indicating that individuals received care from group members. She emphasized that the coexistence of violence and caregiving in Shanidar A challenges simplistic stereotypes of Neanderthals as uncaring or unintelligent.

Source

Gizmodo

Continuez à lire — gratuitement

Créez un compte gratuit pour suivre l'actualité. Aucune carte requise.