Mayor Mamdani Defends Retention of NYPD Commissioner Jessica Tisch Amid Leftist Calls for Removal
New York City Mayor Zohran Mamdani reaffirmed his support for Police Commissioner Jessica Tisch, rejecting pressure from progressive activists to fire her after a recent ICE shooting incident.
New York City Mayor Zohran Mamdani told reporters on Tuesday that he will keep Police Commissioner Jessica Tisch in her post, despite growing demands from members of NYC-DSA and other left-leaning activists to dismiss her following an ICE agent’s fatal shooting in Marble Hill.
"We have delivered the lowest recorded number of murders in our city’s history," Mamdani said, praising the department’s recent crime-reduction record.
The mayor’s decision aligns with the stance taken by most major candidates in the 2025 mayoral race, including former mayoral hopefuls Brad Lander, former governor Andrew Cuomo and former police union leader Curtis Sliwa, all of whom pledged to retain Tisch. Governor Kathy Hochul also urged Mamdani to keep the commissioner, describing the continuity as "important" for the city’s stability.
Activists point to the ICE shooting of Oscar Belgal, captured on video as police cleared protesters outside Allen Hospital, as evidence that the NYPD’s current leadership should be held accountable. NYC-DSA co-chair Grace Mausser noted that Tisch has been in office for ten months and called for a review of use-of-force policies, though she stopped short of demanding an outright dismissal.
Business groups, the Partnership for New York City, and several elected officials, including House Democratic Leader Hakeem Jeffries, have publicly supported Tisch’s retention, citing her managerial experience and the department’s recent decline in homicides. The President of the United States also commented that keeping Tisch was "a good sign," noting her personal connection to his daughter.
Polls from Suffolk University show that 64% of Democratic voters view Mamdani’s decision as pragmatic leadership, while only 19% see it as contradictory to his campaign promises. The mayor’s allies argue that maintaining the commissioner provides a political hedge against future crises that could otherwise jeopardize his broader agenda on housing affordability and child-care funding.
The debate highlights a tension within the city’s progressive movement: balancing calls for police reform with the practical need to preserve funding and institutional support for the mayor’s policy priorities.