Immigration agents accused of failing to identify themselves before shooting Manhattan man
A federal court filing by Oscar Belgal's attorneys claims ICE agents did not identify themselves and used excessive force during an October 8 encounter in Marble Hill, contradicting statements from Homeland Security officials.
A petition filed in Brooklyn federal court on behalf of Oscar Belgal, a 28-year-old Dominican immigrant, alleges that U.S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE) agents ambushed his vehicle in Marble Hill on Oct. 8 without identifying themselves. The filing states the agents, many wearing masks, approached the car with firearms drawn, shattered the driver’s side window and fired at least seven shots, striking Belgal in the neck.
"The men did not identify themselves, show any documents or otherwise communicate with Oscar in any substantive way," the petition reads.
The petition also disputes claims by Homeland Security officials that Belgal was a member of the Trinitarios gang and that he attempted to weaponize his vehicle. According to the filing, video evidence shows Belgal was simply trying to move his car away from the officers and that another vehicle later blocked his path.
After being shot, Belgal reportedly asked for medical assistance, but the filing says ICE agents handcuffed him and left him unattended until New York City police transported him to a hospital. He later learned that the masked men were ICE agents. Doctors indicated he required surgery to remove the bullet.
A Department of Homeland Security spokesperson said the arrest was justified because Belgal was in the country without authorization and allegedly disobeyed ICE commands. The government has been given a deadline to respond to the petition, which also seeks Belgal’s immediate release from ICE custody.
A federal judge previously ordered that Belgal not be removed from the United States or transferred outside the New York City metropolitan area while the case proceeds.