New York's voluntary intoxication exemption hampers prosecution in Cornell fraternity assault case
Solo los hechos

New York's voluntary intoxication exemption hampers prosecution in Cornell fraternity assault case

Resumen

A Cornell University fraternity assault allegation highlights New York's legal exemption for victims who voluntarily consume alcohol or drugs, a provision that prosecutors say prevents criminal charges despite the alleged rape.

A lawsuit filed by a woman identified as Jane Doe alleges that she was sexually assaulted for several hours at a Chi Phi fraternity house at Cornell University after she voluntarily consumed alcohol and was later pressured to take ketamine. Although the Tompkins County district attorney described the conduct as "morally wrong" and "disgusting," he said the state's penal law was not violated because Doe was not rendered incapable of consent by an involuntary drug.

Under New York law, a person is considered "incapable of consent" only when a narcotic or intoxicating substance is administered without consent. The exemption for voluntary intoxication, present in about 19 states, has been criticized by advocates as a barrier to prosecuting sexual assaults.

Assemblyman Jeffrey Dinowitz, who has introduced legislation to eliminate the exemption each session since 2019, said the current rule provides "a virtual get-out-of-jail-free card for somebody who commits a sexual assault" and urged lawmakers to act. The bill has not yet been scheduled for a vote.

RAINN’s vice president for public policy, Stefan Turkheimer, warned that the legal gap discourages survivors from reporting assaults and called for reforms that prioritize victim safety. Similar advocacy led to the passage of the Summer Willis Act in Texas, which revised the state's consent statutes.

In response to the Cornell case, New York State Assembly Speaker Carl Heastie announced the formation of a working group to review sexual assault laws and develop recommendations for the 2027 legislative session, signaling potential momentum for change.

Fuente

CNN

Sigue leyendo, gratis

Crea una cuenta gratis para seguir las noticias. No se requiere tarjeta.