Fantasy analysts flag five players to consider benching for Week 2 of the 2026 NFL season

RotoBaller’s weekly fantasy preview identified five players who may underperform in Week 2 and could be candidates for the bench. Running back Chase Brown recorded 18.8 PPR points in Week 1 against a vulnerable Buccaneers defense, but his 3.7 yards per touch and modest production raise concerns against a strong Texans run defense that limited the league’s 2025 rushing leader to 57 yards.

Quarterback Tyler Shough threw for 410 yards in his Week 1 debut, yet he faces a Baltimore Ravens defense that allowed only 149 net passing yards and forced two turnovers. The Saints’ primary receiver, Chris Olave, is listed as questionable, adding further risk to Shough’s outlook.

Wide receiver Chris Godwin caught four passes for 40 yards in Week 1, but his target share was low compared with teammates and the Browns’ defense ranked among the best against wide receivers last season. Analysts note his production relied heavily on yards after contact, which may be unsustainable.

Running back TreVeyon Henderson returns from injury to face a Pittsburgh Steelers defense that has improved under a new coordinator, allowing just 13 points in its most recent game. The Patriots continue to favor Rhamondre Stevenson, who logged 23 touches in Week 1, limiting Henderson’s opportunity.

Tight end Michael Mayer posted 9.2 PPR points in Week 1, leading the Raiders in targets. However, the Los Angeles Chargers historically limit tight-end production, and Mayer’s career average against them is modest. The analysis suggests managers weigh these factors when setting lineups for the upcoming week.