Experts doubt pipelines can quickly replace Strait of Hormuz for oil shipments
U.S. officials claim new pipelines will make the Strait of Hormuz irrelevant within two years, but analysts say infrastructure limits and regional risks mean the waterway will remain a key chokepoint.
Washington announced sanctions aimed at curbing Iran's influence over the Strait of Hormuz and urged Gulf producers to accelerate pipeline projects that could divert oil flows. Treasury Secretary Scott Bessent told an NBC affiliate that 50% to 70% of energy products normally shipped through the strait could be moved by pipelines within two years, making the waterway “just another body of water.”
Energy analysts and the International Energy Agency (IEA) caution that such a shift is unlikely in the near term. The United Arab Emirates expects a $3 billion pipeline to its Fujairah port to be operational next year, but larger Saudi expansions will take several more years, according to the IEA. Senior oil market analyst Rebecca Schulz said even when major projects are completed, more than 10 million barrels per day – about half of pre-war levels – would still need to pass through the strait to restore Gulf exports.
Former U.S. State Department envoy David Goldwyn noted that the constraints on Hormuz exports are likely to persist for years, given Iran’s demand for payment and the limited prospects for a military solution. Analyst Robert McNally called Bessent’s “irrelevant” prediction “way too strong and overstated,” emphasizing that the strait remains the most critical chokepoint for global energy flows.
Alternative routes such as the Bab el-Mandeb waterway remain vulnerable to attacks by Iran-aligned Houthi rebels, and new pipelines are expected to handle only 10-12 million barrels per day, far below the roughly 20 million barrels that previously moved through Hormuz. Goldwyn described pipelines as “a partial solution.”
The disruption has pushed oil prices above $100 a barrel, raising fuel and food costs worldwide. Analysts anticipate elevated oil, natural gas and food prices for at least the next year, while the IEA warns that the crisis also threatens supply chains for fertilizer, aluminum and other commodities. Renewable energy interest is growing, but experts say it will not offset fossil-fuel price risks in the medium term.
Tracking of tanker movements through Hormuz has become more difficult as vessels disable identification systems and high-resolution satellite imagery is restricted, further complicating assessments of shipping volumes.