Preseason Week 1 ranks rookie quarterbacks, with Allar and Mendoza leading the pack

The preseason opener gave 15 rookie quarterbacks their first NFL snaps, allowing teams to assess depth and future prospects. Drew Allar of the Steelers topped the list, completing 10 of 13 passes for 153 yards, two touchdowns and a rushing score, showing the arm strength and accuracy that made him a notable Penn State prospect. First-round picks Fernando Mendoza (Raiders) and Ty Simpson (Rams) placed second and third, respectively; Mendoza finished 10-for-16 for 97 yards and a touchdown against a Cardinals defense, while Simpson went 21-for-25 for 190 yards and two touchdowns, both to running back Dean Connors.

Other notable performances included Joe Fagnano of the Ravens, who posted a 79% completion rate (22-of-28) and a touchdown in a largely sack-free outing, and Cade Klubnik of the Jets, who threw efficiently in relief of Geno Smith, completing five of seven passes for 56 yards and a score. Undrafted players such as Jalon Daniels (Buccaneers) and Joey Aguilar (Jaguars) also made impacts, with Daniels adding a rushing touchdown and Aguilar completing his sole attempt for 43 yards.

The rankings considered completion percentages, yards, touchdowns, sacks taken and overall command of the offense. Several rookies, including Carson Beck (Cardinals) and Haynes King (Panthers), impressed in the Hall of Fame Game but missed subsequent action due to injuries. The analysis suggests that strong preseason showings could influence roster decisions, with many of the evaluated quarterbacks positioned as potential backups or practice-squad candidates for the upcoming regular season.