Maine Democrats Debate Options to Replace Graham Platner Ahead of July Convention
Eight Democratic candidates discussed their qualifications to challenge Sen. Susan Collins in a two-hour debate, with the party set to select a new Senate nominee at a July 25 convention.
Eight Democrats vying to replace Graham Platner as the party’s Senate nominee addressed a small audience in a two-hour debate on Thursday, outlining their experience and policy positions ahead of a July 25 convention that will choose the candidate to face Republican Sen. Susan Collins. The first hour featured four candidates who had previously run in statewide primaries: former public-health official Nirav Shah, former Senate President Troy Jackson, Secretary of State Shenna Bellows, and former Capitol Hill staffer Jordan Wood. The second hour included lesser-known contenders such as Dan Kleban, founder of the Maine Beer Company, who entered the race after former Gov. Janet Mills withdrew her campaign.
All participants emphasized progressive priorities, with Jackson and Shah both endorsing Medicare for All and Shah calling for the abolition of U.S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE). Wood echoed Platner’s criticism of Israel’s actions in Gaza, while Bellows reiterated Platner’s claim that “the democracy we thought we had has been deeply corrupted.”
The debate also touched on the recent fatal shooting of an immigrant by an ICE officer in Biddeford. Shah condemned the incident, referencing a three-year-old girl who will never see her father again. Bellows and Jackson described ICE as a “rogue agency” that brings “heartache and racism,” and Wood suggested stricter identification requirements for ICE agents.
Candidates focused their attacks on Sen. Collins and President Donald Trump rather than on each other, reflecting the strategic need to build alliances for the upcoming convention, where 601 delegates will vote in multiple rounds. Shah’s remarks on Defense Secretary Pete Hegseth and Jackson’s appeal to working-class voters were among the few moments of distinct policy critique.
The debate highlighted the challenge of finding a candidate who can match Platron’s previous media profile and fundraising ability as Democrats prepare for what is expected to be a competitive Senate race in November.