Florida State coach Mike Norvell faces criticism over new coordinator hires amid poor performance

Florida State University’s football program has struggled to rebound after a 49-point loss to Notre Dame in November 2024. Athletic director Michael Alford dismissed offensive coordinator Alex Atkins, defensive coordinator Adam Fuller and wide receivers coach Ron Dugans the day after the defeat, while head coach Mike Norvell retained his position under an eight-year, $84 million contract signed the previous offseason. Legendary defensive line coach Odell Haggins was moved to an off-field role.

In the final weeks of the 2024 season, the Seminoles, sitting at 1-9, faced a bye week, an FCS opponent and a struggling Florida team. Norvell used the break to hire new coordinators for the 2025 season. He appointed Gus Malzahn as offensive coordinator, a former mentor who previously ran a similar offensive system, and Tony White as defensive coordinator, introducing a 3-3-5 scheme not previously used at the FBS level. Both coordinators brought several assistants: Malzahn added offensive line coach Herb Hand and wide receivers coach Tim Harris Jr. from UCF, while White recruited defensive line coach Terrance Knighton and safeties coach Evan Cooper from Nebraska.

After 14 games under the new staff, the Seminoles have lost eight of their last ten contests against Power Five opponents. Despite winning the turnover margin, time-of-possession and committing fewer penalties in a recent home loss, the team was unable to secure a victory. "Tonight, coming off of it, just another close game, a lot of one plays," Norvell said in the post-game press conference, noting defensive lapses and missed offensive opportunities.

Offensively, expectations were modest entering the season, but the unit has struggled to sustain drives, converting only two of 15 third-down attempts in the latest game. Malzahn retired before spring practice, leaving Norvell to call plays, a role in which the team has not shown improvement.

Defensively, White’s 3-3-5 scheme has produced three turnovers but allowed nearly 600 yards, 8.7 yards per play and 8 of 14 third-down conversions. The Seminoles also surrendered three receptions of 50 yards or more. The defensive line, coached by Knighton, has not generated consistent pressure; the team recorded no sacks and pass-rush grades remained low according to Pro Football Focus. Safeties have struggled with coverage, with transfers CJ Richard Jr. and Ma’Khi Jones posting grades below 60.

Analysts note that while hiring experienced coordinators can address systemic issues, the recent changes have not translated into on-field success for Florida State. The continued poor performance raises questions about Norvell’s future with the program.