U.S. Supreme Court to hear case on forfeiture of pilot's plane over six-pack of beer
The Supreme Court will review whether Alaska's seizure of a bush pilot's aircraft for transporting a six-pack of beer violates the Eighth Amendment's Excessive Fines Clause.
The U.S. Supreme Court agreed on Monday to hear arguments in a case involving Alaska bush pilot Kenneth Jouppi, who contends that the state's forfeiture of his 1969 Cessna, valued at about $95,000, breaches the Constitution's Excessive Fines Clause. Jouppi was convicted of a misdemeanor after a passenger was found with a six-pack of beer on a flight to Beaver, a village where alcohol is prohibited. The Alaska Supreme Court upheld the forfeiture, but Jouppi appealed, saying the penalty is disproportionate to the offense.
"I’m in my 80s now, and I’ve been fighting this for over a decade because I see it as my duty to ensure that the Bill of Rights actually means something in protecting against government overreach," Jouppi said in a statement from his attorneys at the Institute for Justice.
Jouppi and his company were charged with knowingly transporting alcohol into a dry community; the passenger pleaded guilty, and a jury convicted Jouppi and his company. He received a three-day jail sentence. His lawyers argue that the Alaska Supreme Court evaluated the case in abstract terms without considering the broader context, and that the forfeiture is an excessive fine under established Supreme Court precedent.
Alaska Attorney General lawyers counter that the state court applied a multi-factor test to assess proportionality and that Jouppi has not demonstrated that the forfeiture is grossly disproportional. They note that alcohol importation can be a serious issue in rural Alaska and that aircraft are sometimes used to transport contraband.
The Supreme Court is expected to hear oral arguments in the fall, which could clarify the scope of the Excessive Fines Clause in forfeiture cases.