Texas family seeks answers after mother killed in Tesla crash
Just the facts

Texas family seeks answers after mother killed in Tesla crash

Summary

The daughter of Martha Avila, who died when a Tesla collided with her home, says investigators must determine whether the vehicle's driver-assist system was active, while the family remains displaced.

A 76-year-old Texas woman died after a Tesla struck her home, prompting her family to call for a thorough investigation into the vehicle’s driver-assist technology. The driver, Michael Butler, told Harris County investigators that the car’s automated system was engaged at the time of the crash, which occurred on a road with a 25 mph speed limit but appeared to involve a much higher speed before the vehicle became airborne and entered the residence’s living room. Butler showed no signs of intoxication and has been cooperating with authorities.

Jennifer Barbour, the victim’s daughter, said she heard a loud boom and saw windows shatter, initially thinking it was a gas explosion. She described the scene as filling with smoke and expressed concern for her children, who were present at the time.

"We were outside, and I heard a boom and all our windows broke in the back," Barbour told NewsNation.

"I thought it was a gas explosion. It really freaked me out because I knew it was big. The whole house filled with smoke, and I was terrified for my kids."

Barbour, a software tester, said she is not ready to blame Tesla directly but believes a malfunction is possible given the vehicle’s speed. The family has been displaced and is staying in a hotel while a GoFundMe campaign seeks to cover expenses.

The crash remains under investigation, and Tesla has not responded to requests for comment. Data from the National Highway Traffic Safety Administration show that out of 3,866 crashes involving advanced driver-assistance systems since 2021, Tesla vehicles account for the majority. Law professor Bryant Walker Smith noted the incident could be an example of “sudden unintended acceleration,” a complaint reported across multiple manufacturers.

"The driver says the car suddenly started going really fast and couldn’t slow it down," Smith said.

FL Plus

Read the full story with FL Plus

Unlimited news plus the analysis behind every headline.

Unlimited news feed
See why each story scored
Full fact-check details