Texas teen sentenced to 35 years for murder after self-defense claim rejected
A jury convicted Karmelo Anthony of murder and sentenced him to 35 years in prison for the stabbing death of fellow student Austin Metcalf, rejecting the defendant's self-defense argument.
A Texas jury found Karmelo Anthony guilty of murder and sentenced him to 35 years in a state prison after a brief deliberation lasting less than three hours. The conviction stems from the April 2, 2025, stabbing of fellow high-school athlete Austin Metcalv at a track meet in Frisco, which prosecutors described as an intentional attack. Anthony’s defense had argued that he acted in self-defense after being taunted and shoved by Metcalv and his teammates.
During a CBS Mornings interview, Anthony’s mother, Kala Hayes, said her son “didn’t mean to hurt anyone” and was “defending himself.” His father, Andrew Anthony, expressed that “nobody wins” in the situation and criticized the jury composition, noting it was all-White.
Metcalv’s father, Jeff Metcalv, described the verdict as “bittersweet,” saying he has forgiven Anthony to avoid carrying “rage” and “hate.” He added that his son will never return and that “he deserves what he gets because we’re all responsible for our actions.”
Anthony’s attorneys filed a notice of appeal, with Dallas-based appellate lawyer David Coale indicating the appeal will focus on jury selection procedures and the removal of Black jurors. The family also alleges that witnesses gave inconsistent statements.
Collins County District Attorney Greg Willis said after the verdict that “justice was served” and that jurors “cooperated fully and testified truthfully.”
Both families have reported receiving threats following the trial.