Senator Mark Kelly Sues Pentagon Over Censure and Potential Demotion
Senator Mark Kelly has filed a lawsuit against the Pentagon, challenging a censure and potential demotion following his participation in a video urging military personnel to refuse unlawful orders.
Senator Mark Kelly, a Democrat from Arizona and retired U.S. Navy captain, has initiated legal action against the Pentagon, including Defense Secretary Pete Hegseth, contesting a censure and potential demotion linked to his involvement in a video advising military members to disobey unlawful orders.
In November, Kelly, alongside five other Democratic lawmakers with military or intelligence backgrounds, appeared in a video emphasizing the duty of service members to refuse illegal commands. The video did not mention President Donald Trump or specific policies but was released amid heightened military activities and threats, notably toward Venezuela.
President Trump criticized the video, labeling it as "seditious behavior from traitors... punishable by death," and later added, "Hang them George Washington would!" Subsequently, Defense Secretary Hegseth issued a formal censure to Kelly, initiating proceedings that could lead to a reduction in his military rank and retirement benefits.
On January 12, 2026, Kelly filed a lawsuit in federal court in Washington, D.C., asserting that the censure and potential demotion infringe upon his constitutional rights, particularly the First Amendment. The lawsuit seeks to halt any disciplinary measures, describing them as unlawful and unconstitutional.
Legal experts have expressed skepticism regarding the Pentagon's actions. Eugene Fidell, a senior scholar specializing in military law at Yale Law School, noted that retired officers cannot be demoted for actions taken post-retirement. He also highlighted that any court-martial would require substantial evidence of criminality, which appears lacking in this case.
Kelly emphasized the broader implications of the Pentagon's actions, stating that the censure sends a "chilling message to every retired member of the military: If you speak out and say something that the president or secretary of defense doesn't like, you will be censured, threatened with demotion, or even prosecuted."
The Pentagon has refrained from commenting on the ongoing litigation.
Source
SlateFact-checking
Fact-check the facts of the article using external sources and databases.