New York City unveils plan to close Rikers Island jail and replace it with borough-based facilities
Just the facts

New York City unveils plan to close Rikers Island jail and replace it with borough-based facilities

Summary

Mayor Zohran Mamdani announced a detailed roadmap to shut down the Rikers Island detention center, build four smaller jails across the city and invest in alternatives to incarceration.

New York City officials on Friday presented a comprehensive plan to close the Rikers Island pre-trial detention center and replace it with four smaller facilities in Brooklyn, Manhattan, Queens and the Bronx. The proposal, first approved by the City Council in 2019 with a 2027 deadline, acknowledges that the original target will not be met but sets a new timeline for the transition.

Mayor Zohran Mamdani told NPR that the jail has become “a moral stain on our city” and that his administration will not accept outdated public-safety approaches. He noted that previous administrations did not advance the closure and said his team aims to be the first to deliver on the promise.

The plan calls for the new borough-based jails to be closer to courts and public transit, improving access for families, lawyers and service providers. Together they would house about 2,000 fewer inmates than the roughly 6,600 currently held at Rikers. The city will invest more than $250 million in alternatives such as diversion programs, electronic monitoring, supportive housing and mental-health treatment to reduce the jail population.

Insha Rahman, president of the Vera Institute of Justice, said the effort could serve as a model for other large cities. The remediation manager, Nicholas Deml, cited observations from a recent trip to German prisons, noting that “human dignity at the center of incarceration” differs from current U.S. practices.

"While German correctional systems are not directly transferable to New York, they reflect a fundamentally different orientation — one that places human dignity at the center of incarceration," Deml wrote.

The city also appointed a “Close Rikers Czar” and named former inmate Stanley Richards as commissioner of the Department of Correction. Richards emphasized the need to change the facility’s culture, drawing on his observations abroad.

"Part of the work that I’m doing is showing value and appreciation to our staff so they begin to expand their capacity to show that same value and humanity to the people who come to us," Richards said.

Judicial officials highlighted that long pre-trial detention times contribute to overcrowding. Chief administrative judge Joseph Zayas said addressing case backlogs will require coordinated efforts across the justice system.

Critics warned that without a sufficient reduction in the jail population, the new facilities could inherit existing problems. Vincent Schiraldi, former DOC commissioner, cautioned that inaccurate forecasts could leave the city with crowded jails.

The plan also includes a task force to accelerate court processing, though judges and district attorneys operate independently of the mayor’s office.

Overall, officials described the initiative as a long-term effort to transform New York’s approach to public safety, acknowledging that cultural change and infrastructure upgrades will take time.

Source

NPR

Keep reading — for free

Create a free account to follow the news. No card required.