Joo Chiat trial introduces Shibuya-style scramble crossing, drawing mixed reactions
Juste les faits

Joo Chiat trial introduces Shibuya-style scramble crossing, drawing mixed reactions

Résumé

A three-month trial of a scramble crossing at the Joo Chiat Road and East Coast Road junction has been welcomed by pedestrians and local businesses, while some motorists and residents express concerns about longer waits and altered traffic routes.

A three-month trial of a "Shibuya-style" scramble crossing began on Monday at the junction of Joo Chiat Road and East Coast Road. The system allows pedestrians to cross from all directions, including diagonally, while vehicle movements are halted for a brief phase. The trial is part of ongoing efforts to improve traffic flow and pedestrian safety in the busy area.

Local business leaders expressed optimism that the novelty could boost footfall. > "Katong-Joo Chiat continues to be a really exciting place, flooded with a lot of visitors. But really, because of past car accidents, safety is a priority for us," said Edmond Wong, president of the Katong-Joo Chiat Business Association and co-owner of the rice dumpling shop Kim Choo. Retail workers noted early interest from visitors seeking the "Shibuya thing," though they cautioned that the longer-term impact on sales remains unclear.

Pedestrians reported shorter overall crossing times despite waiting up to two minutes for the green phase. A 70-year-old resident who lives in Tokyo described the new arrangement as "way better" than the previous stop-and-go system, allowing her to cross the intersection directly. Visitors from other parts of the city said the design was "very special" and might encourage more frequent trips to the neighbourhood.

Motorists, however, highlighted potential drawbacks. The trial permanently restricts the right-turn from East Coast Road onto Joo Chiat Road, requiring drivers to use alternative routes such as Marine Parade Road. Some drivers said they would avoid the junction once the trial is fully implemented because of longer waiting times. Bar owner Tan Kay Chuan noted that traffic appeared "visibly smoother" but acknowledged that vehicles now wait longer at the lights, adding about five minutes to his commute.

Member of Parliament Goh Pei Ming said the trial will be evaluated to determine whether it becomes a permanent feature, noting that the idea originated from a grassroots leader concerned about pedestrian safety at the busy intersection.

Researchers from the Singapore University of Technology and Design highlighted the junction's suitability for a scramble crossing, citing its compact layout and diverse destinations that generate multi-directional pedestrian flows. They emphasized that safety improvements and reduced decision-making for pedestrians are key benefits, while also noting that not all intersections would gain from such a system. Past trials at Orchard Road were discontinued after failing to meet objectives such as generating sufficient pedestrian usage and avoiding increased congestion.

The trial will continue for three months, during which authorities will monitor safety outcomes, pedestrian waiting times and overall traffic conditions to decide on a permanent implementation.

Source

CNA

Continuez à lire — gratuitement

Créez un compte gratuit pour suivre l'actualité. Aucune carte requise.