Dutch court rejects JLR's penalty claim against BYD and lifts evidence seizure
सिर्फ तथ्य

Dutch court rejects JLR's penalty claim against BYD and lifts evidence seizure

सारांश

The Hague District Court ruled that BYD complied with cooperation obligations, rejecting Jaguar Land Rover's $553,850 penalty claim and ordering JLR to pay $28,110 in legal costs.

A Dutch district court in The Hague dismissed Jaguar Land Rover's (JLR) request for $553,850 in penalties against BYD over an August 24 evidence seizure, finding that BYD had fulfilled its cooperation duties. The judgment noted that bailiffs had not specified the actions required of BYD nor set reasonable deadlines, and therefore could not justify the claimed penalties. JLR was ordered to reimburse BYD $28,110 in legal expenses, a correction the automaker did not contest.

The seizure involved laptops, a Synology network-attached storage device, Microsoft 365 data and Tencent WeCom messages. BYD employees delivered laptops several hours after the bailiffs' request, and a China-based IT team provided Microsoft 365 access later that day. Although temporary restrictions were placed on the data, BYD restored access promptly. For WeCom, BYD supplied login credentials, which allowed bailiffs to view messages but not export them; the court considered this sufficient compliance.

The court also lifted the seizure, concluding that the seized material was not necessary for JLR's EU-registered design claims. Both parties agreed that BYD had not offered or sold the Ti 7 model in the EU, and no financial damage from potential future sales had occurred. Consequently, the evidence request did not meet the requirement of relating to an existing legal relationship under Dutch civil procedure.

Separate proceedings continue in The Hague and Rotterdam concerning JLR's design, copyright and imitation allegations. JLR reported a reduced after-tax loss for the quarter ended September 30, 2026, and a 40.6% year-on-year decline in retail sales in China, attributing the drop to the cessation of local production by its joint venture with Chery.

स्रोत

CarNewsChina.com

पहली बार यहां रिपोर्ट किया गया

पढ़ते रहें — निःशुल्क

समाचार फ़ॉलो करने के लिए मुफ़्त खाता बनाएँ। कार्ड की आवश्यकता नहीं।