Victorian Labor MPs question premier's $204 million youth detention plan
Labor members across factions expressed concern that Premier Ben Carroll's new "tough love" scheme for young offenders may alienate voters and conflict with the party's values.
Premier Ben Carroll announced a $204 million program that would place children charged with low- and mid-level offences in secure facilities such as the former Malmsbury youth justice centre for education, drug and alcohol treatment and life-skills training. Carroll said the measure aims to break cycles of crime and give young people a chance to turn their lives around.
Former Victorian commissioner for Aboriginal children and young people Meena Singh, now a Monash law professor, said she was "quite horrified" by the proposal, adding that it "paints the imprisonment of children as therapeutic" and risks punishing trauma rather than addressing behaviour.
The Victorian Aboriginal Legal Service described the plan as "mandatory sentencing dressed up as political leadership," while the Justice Reform Initiative called it a "dramatically disproportionate response." Trade union leader Luke Hilakari criticised the policy on social media, suggesting it would benefit the Liberal party and urging the government to address underlying disadvantage instead.
A DemosAU poll released on Monday showed Labor’s primary-vote support at 18%, the lowest in its history, and a RedBridge poll later reported a 23% primary vote, placing Labor 18 points behind the Coalition on crime issues. Several unnamed Labor MPs said the proposal could hand the Liberals a political advantage and questioned the party’s messaging to Victorian voters.
Internal party sources noted that the policy has sparked division between the party’s right-leaning members, who view it as insufficient for working-class concerns, and left-leaning members, who see it as a departure from Labor’s core values. The debate comes as the party also faces criticism for its handling of police station closures and other crime-related initiatives.
The Greens have responded by promoting an open ticket strategy, aiming to attract voters dissatisfied with Labor’s recent campaign focus on law and order and infrastructure projects.