CPCB's Diwali AQI calculations understate Delhi's pollution, analysis finds
Solo los hechos

CPCB's Diwali AQI calculations understate Delhi's pollution, analysis finds

Resumen

An analysis by Hindustan Times shows that the Central Pollution Control Board excluded extreme hourly readings from its Diwali air-quality index, resulting in lower reported AQI values for Delhi.

During Diwali night, Delhi’s monitoring stations recorded PM2.5 concentrations up to 62 times the national daily limit, yet the official air-quality index (AQI) reported by the Central Pollution Control Board (CPCB) fell from 373 at 11 p.m. on November 8 to 366 at 6 a.m. the next morning. The board explained that its instruments are calibrated only up to 1,000 µg/m³ and that readings above this threshold are excluded from the 24-hour average, which it says is a design feature of the index.

Hindustan Times tested the board’s defence by recalculating the AQI using CPCB’s own methodology but including the omitted hours. The re-calculation raised the city’s 9 a.m. AQI from 370 to 393 and the 4 p.m. bulletin figure from 344 to 372. The analysis identified three problems: the index caps at 500, so extreme readings cannot increase the score further; discarding hours can only lower the average; and ten of the city’s worst-hit stations were removed from the average altogether.

Under CPCB’s rules, an hourly PM2.5 reading of about 420 µg/m³ already yields the maximum AQI score of 500, meaning that readings of 450 µg/m³, 999 µg/m³ or even 3,744 µg/m³ all receive the same score. Consequently, counting the omitted hours would not have pushed the AQI beyond its ceiling, but it would have prevented the index from being artificially lowered.

At stations such as Nehru Nagar, the official AQI dropped from 387 to 344 after the board excluded eight hours with concentrations between 1,658 µg/m³ and 2,808 µg/m³. Including those hours would have raised the AQI to 396. Similar patterns were observed at other sites, where the removal of high-pollution hours caused the AQI to fall, while stations with uninterrupted data saw the index rise.

The CPCB also omitted stations that lacked the required 16 hours of data, removing ten of Delhi’s 59 monitoring sites from the city-wide average. If those stations were included, the number classified as “severe” would increase from 14 to 27 for the 9 a.m. reading.

The board cited the U.S. Environmental Protection Agency’s guidance, which allows agencies to assign a value to readings beyond the instrument’s range. However, the CPCB’s own data show that its published AQI figures were lower than what its measurements and formula would produce when all hours are counted, indicating under-reporting regardless of intent.

CPCB said the practice is under review and that internal deliberations are ongoing regarding data beyond the system’s design range.

Sigue leyendo, gratis

Crea una cuenta gratis para seguir las noticias. No se requiere tarjeta.