NFL Week 9 overreactions examined ahead of trade deadline
Analyst assesses which post-game reactions to Week 9 are justified and which are exaggerated as teams approach the NFL trade deadline.
As the NFL trade deadline approaches, analysts review five storylines from Week 9 to separate legitimate concerns from overblown reactions.
The Cincinnati Bengals, now 6-2 and tied for the AFC North lead, have been praised for quarterback Joe Burrow’s performance against the Falcons. While the team’s running game appears weak, the analyst notes that the Bengals could still explore upgrades at running back, offensive line or safety, but does not deem a major trade essential at this stage.
"The Bengals are one trade away from the Super Bowl" – verdict: not an overreaction.
In Dallas, the Cowboys’ recent win was followed by a loss of a double-digit lead, leaving them 4-5. The analyst argues that expecting another major defensive acquisition is premature, given the team’s limited draft capital and a young defense still developing.
"The Cowboys should make another big addition on defense" – verdict: overreaction.
The wide-receiver market is expected to be active, with several teams reportedly interested in players such as Brian Thomas Jr., Josh Downs, Keenan Allen and Calvin Ridley. The analyst predicts aggressive activity but does not view the speculation as excessive.
"Multiple wide receivers will change teams the next two days" – verdict: not an overreaction.
The New York Giants, 5-2-1 and atop the NFC East, have struggled in the running game, averaging 2.6 yards per carry. While a running-back addition could help, the analyst cautions against sacrificing future draft assets for a single player.
"The Giants should make a big move for a running back and put the NFC East away" – verdict: overreaction.
Finally, the Green Bay Packers, despite a strong passing display by Jordan Love, continue to rank near the bottom in rushing yards. The analyst sees the recent rushing success as an outlier and advises the Packers to seek long-term solutions for their ground game before the deadline.
"The Packers must build Jordan Love a running game" – verdict: not an overreaction.