Victim's appeal leads to life without parole and isolation at Dame Phyllis Frost Centre
Juste les faits

Victim's appeal leads to life without parole and isolation at Dame Phyllis Frost Centre

Résumé

The Victorian Court of Appeal increased Erin Patterson's sentence to life without parole and ordered her placement in solitary confinement, prompting concerns about her safety among other inmates.

A Victorian Court of Appeal on Friday replaced Erin Patterson's 33-year minimum term with a life sentence without the possibility of parole after finding her actions "extraordinarily cold and calculated." Patterson, a 52-year-old mother from Leongatha, was convicted of poisoning three members of her estranged husband’s family with death-cap mushrooms in July 2023. The court said the original sentence did not reflect the seriousness of the premeditated murders.

Patterson will serve her sentence at the Dame Phyllis Frost Centre, a maximum-security women’s prison in Melbourne’s west, where she has been placed in solitary confinement for her own safety. She will spend most of her time in a small cell known to inmates as “the slot,” with meals delivered through a trap door and limited contact with other prisoners.

Former inmate Kelly Flanagan told the outlet that Patterson is likely to face hostility from other inmates, describing a scenario in which she would be shouted at throughout the night. Flanagan, who was released in March 2024, said the prison environment often results in inmates receiving treatment that reflects how they behave.

Retired surgeon and solitary-confinement advocate Clive Solomon criticised the practice of prolonged isolation, calling it “anathema to society” and noting that even limited amenities such as a computer or books cannot replace human interaction.

During the appeal hearing, Patterson watched the proceedings remotely from her prison cell. She maintained her innocence, claiming the poisoning was accidental, but a jury had previously found her guilty beyond reasonable doubt. Her legal team argued procedural errors, including alleged mishandling of evidence and juror sequestration, but Justice McLeish rejected all grounds for appeal and affirmed the new sentence.

The court emphasized that the re-sentencing aims to uphold the societal value placed on each human life and to provide a clear denunciation of the crimes.

Continuez à lire — gratuitement

Créez un compte gratuit pour suivre l'actualité. Aucune carte requise.