Michigan defeats Rutgers 28-21 amid offensive and special teams concerns

Michigan recorded a 28-21 victory over Rutgers on Saturday, moving to a 5-3 record for the season. Quarterback Tommy Carr completed 22 of 27 passes for 266 yards and a touchdown, added 54 rushing yards and scored two rushing touchdowns, which proved crucial to the win. The Wolverines amassed 427 total yards and converted 12 of 16 third-down attempts, though much of the production came against a defense ranked near the bottom nationally.

Analysts noted that offensive coordinator Jason Beck’s play selection, including delayed handoffs and the Rhino formation, drew criticism, and the offensive line’s protection and run blocking were described as subpar. Kicker Trey Butkowski missed four field-goal attempts in the game, including attempts from 48 and 35 yards, prompting calls for more fourth-down attempts in field-goal range if the issue persists.

Defensively, Michigan limited Rutgers to 249 total yards. Rutgers quarterback AJ Surace completed three of 12 passes for 123 yards and a touchdown, and did not finish a pass in the second half. The Wolverines allowed an 80-yard touchdown pass, a 32-yard pass and runs of 56 and 20 yards, but otherwise performed solidly.

Head coach Kyle Whittingham, who was favored by 16.5 points entering the game, was observed speaking sparingly on the sidelines. His comments at halftime and after the game focused on the need for improvement, though observers questioned the effectiveness of his communication style.