Pentagon disclosure of fired general's polygraph results raises privacy law concerns
仅事实

Pentagon disclosure of fired general's polygraph results raises privacy law concerns

摘要

A Pentagon statement that Lt. Gen. Brett Sylvia failed three polygraph tests and allegedly leaked classified information has prompted attorneys to question whether the disclosure violates the Privacy Act of 1974.

Defense Secretary Pete Hegseth dismissed Lt. Gen. Brett Sylvia, the Joint Staff’s director of strategy, plans and policy, after an internal investigation identified "severe misconduct." A Pentagon official later told media outlets that Sylvia had failed three polygraph examinations and was accused of leaking classified material about Iran and the Russia-Ukraine war to journalists.

Attorney Brad Moss said the Privacy Act of 1974 generally bars federal agencies from releasing personal information from an employee’s file without consent, and that verbal disclosures can also breach the law.

"It defies belief to see … [the] leaking of Privacy Act-protected information of an employee in order to accuse that same employee of themselves being accused of unauthorized leaks," Moss told CBS News.

Former Judge Advocate General officer Cody Harnish echoed the concern, noting that polygraph results are protected records and that the statement also revealed the existence of a pending counter-intelligence investigation and a Justice Department referral, potentially constituting unlawful command influence.

Retired Lt. Col. Frank Rosenblatt disputed the privacy-law argument, arguing that polygraph data, which is not admissible in court, should not be used as evidence against the general.

Pentagon spokesperson Sean Parnell later issued a brief statement on X emphasizing the department’s "zero tolerance for the intentional, unauthorized disclosure of classified information," without naming Sylvia or repeating the earlier allegations.

The incident occurs amid a broader crackdown on alleged leaks, with more than 20 senior defense officials having left their positions since Hegseth took office at the start of the second Trump administration. Critics note that previous leak investigations have sometimes concluded without charges, raising questions about the balance between security measures and individual rights.

来源

CBS News

继续阅读——免费

创建免费账户以关注新闻。无需银行卡。