Finance Ministry defends IDBI Bank stake sale valuation and process
Juste les faits

Finance Ministry defends IDBI Bank stake sale valuation and process

Résumé

The Ministry of Finance said the valuation and bidding procedures for the sale of a 60.72% stake in IDBI Bank were conducted according to delegated powers and independent assessments, adding Rs 3,917 crore to the transaction value.

The Ministry of Finance issued a clarification on Oct. 29 defending the valuation and bidding process for the strategic privatisation of IDBI Bank. It said the Core Group of Secretaries on Disinvestment (CGD) was authorised by the Cabinet Committee on Economic Affairs to determine the "best-offer" round and that this discretion increased the overall transaction value by Rs 3,917 crore.

The Cabinet Committee on Economic Affairs approved the sale of a combined 60.72% stake to Fairfax Financial Holdings at an acquisition price of Rs 81 per share, valuing the transaction at roughly Rs 53,000 crore. The ministry noted that the initial bid round, conducted in FY 2025-26 by the Department of Investment and Public Asset Management (DIPAM), followed internal guidelines rather than strict rules.

"The press note dated Oct. 14 clearly explains that there is no a-priori benchmark for bidding. Bidders submit their own valuations confidentially, and independent agencies provide a contemporaneous fair valuation used as a comparator," the release said.

The ministry explained that the valuation methodology was reviewed by the CGD in April 2026 before inviting best-offer bids. Independent valuation agencies worked on revised valuations after the March 31, 2026 financial accounts were released, with the process remaining double-blind: bidders did not see the valuations and valuators did not see the bids. Only the CGD received the full set of information to assess bid reasonableness.

Two separate advisers performed the valuation using distinct methods. The primary technique was the Market Multiple method, specifically the Comparable Company Method, which compared IDBI Bank with listed public-sector banks because suitable comparable transactions were unavailable. The release highlighted that IDBI, formerly a government-owned bank, has been treated as a private bank for regulatory purposes since 2019, though the government and LIC retain majority ownership.

The asset valuation also incorporated additional value for disputed tax demands, which were indemnified for qualified bidders. The ministry said the potential tax liability was low (Rs 627 crore) and revenue-neutral for the government, while the bid-discovered price added Rs 3,917 crore to the transaction value.

The clarification responded to a Businessworld report that cited an internal DIPAM note alleging that reserve prices were discarded and valuations were adjusted to favour the buyer. The ministry’s statement refuted those claims, emphasizing the independent and transparent nature of the process.

Continuez à lire — gratuitement

Créez un compte gratuit pour suivre l'actualité. Aucune carte requise.