Canadian provinces split over permanent daylight time as health experts warn of winter sleep impacts
Several western provinces are adopting permanent daylight time while most of the country keeps the biannual clock change, prompting researchers to caution that later winter sunrise could affect sleep and health.
Most of British Columbia, Alberta, Manitoba and the Northwest Territories will stop changing clocks twice a year, joining Yukon and much of Saskatchewan in adopting permanent daylight time. The majority of Ontario, Quebec and the Atlantic provinces will still turn clocks back on Nov. 1 for the end of daylight-saving time. Quebec's premier, Paul St-Pierre Plamondon, said the province plans to end the twice-yearly change but has not yet decided which time to keep, pending expert consultation.
Researchers note that permanent standard time, which aligns with the fall clock setting, matches the body’s internal clock better than permanent daylight time. Joseph De Koninck, an emeritus psychology professor at the University of Ottawa, said the spring forward shift is especially disruptive because it removes an hour of sleep and creates a mismatch between the biological clock and solar time.
Michael Antle, head of the psychology department at the University of Calgary, argued that permanent daylight time would push already late winter sunrise times in Alberta an hour later, increasing “social jetlag.” He cited studies linking later sunsets to reduced sleep, higher obesity, diabetes and heart-disease rates, and Russian research showing higher winter depression among youths under permanent daylight time. Antle suggested a compromise of keeping the spring forward and fall back changes to preserve evening daylight while avoiding a year-round winter mismatch.
The differing provincial policies create a natural experiment for researchers, who hope to compare mental-health outcomes, traffic incidents, school performance and workplace attendance across regions. De Koninck expects public reaction to the new schedule before long-term data are available, noting that people may not fully understand the implications of permanent daylight time until they experience darker winter mornings. He warned that prolonged sleep deprivation can lead to a range of psychological and physical problems.