UK insiders say Rosebank oilfield can be approved without breaching emission targets
Government sources claim the Rosebank project complies with Britain’s carbon budget because exported oil’s emissions are counted abroad, while climate groups warn it undermines net-zero goals.
Government insiders told the Guardian that the Rosebank oilfield can be given the go-ahead without violating the United Kingdom’s climate commitments, as the emissions from burning the oil abroad would not count against domestic carbon budgets.
Energy Secretary Miatta Fahnbulleh has faced pressure from cabinet colleagues, including Chancellor John Healey, who are advocating approval, while she previously indicated a possible rejection. One source said, "> Miatta has more latitude than you might think," referring to the legal framework that excludes exported emissions from the UK’s carbon accounting.
Environmental groups such as Greenpeace and Friends of the Earth have written to the prime minister urging a broader assessment of the cumulative impact of North Sea drilling, Heathrow expansion and heat-pump subsidies, arguing that the decision should not be evaluated in isolation.
Treasury officials note that the department has already factored in several billion pounds of tax revenue from the project, and a rejection could create a fiscal shortfall. A source added, "> The climate case against was never the direct emissions. Instead it was the leadership position … the power of a G7 producer seeking to put that into action is the climate point, not the direct emissions."
University College London climate researcher Greg Muttitt criticized the recent approval of the Jackdaw gasfield and warned that Rosebank could generate roughly seven times more emissions. He acknowledged, however, that "the UK government is not going to find itself in any international court if it approves Rosebank" because most of the oil would be exported.
A 2024 court ruling required ministers to consider emissions from both drilling and the eventual burning of oil. Experts estimate Rosebank could add about one million tonnes of CO₂ by 2042, within the UK’s overall limit of 90 million tonnes. Fahnbulleh noted that the earlier Jackdaw approval was justified on national energy-security grounds, a rationale she says does not automatically apply to Rosebank.
Supporters of the project cite potential tax receipts of £500 million a year, job creation and investment, while opponents argue any new oil development hampers the country’s net-zero objectives. The final decision remains with Fahnbulleh, though senior ministers have interpreted the prime minister’s call for a “pragmatic” approach to oil and gas as tacit support for approval.