Israeli Military Leaders Assess Strategic Shifts After October 7 Attack
Retired Maj-Gen. Nimrod Aloni and reserve Brig-Gen. Guy Hazoot discuss the limitations of Israel's pre-war defence doctrine and the challenges of confronting Hamas, Hezbollah and Iran.
In an interview with Diplomaatia, retired Maj-Gen. Nimrod Aloni and reserve Brig-Gen. Guy Hazoot examined Israel's security strategy before and after the October 7, 2023 attacks. They said the pre-war approach relied on containment, keeping the Gaza, West Bank, northern front and Iran separate, while recent operations have aimed to weaken adversaries across all fronts.
"For more than 10 years, Israel chose to contain a situation in which Iran, the head of the octopus, had encircled it with a ring of fire on seven fronts," Hazoot said, noting that Iran has supported militias in the Galilee, Golan Heights, Gaza envelope and Iraq.
The interviewers asked how the October 7 events exposed flaws in the earlier doctrine. Hazoot argued that Hamas and Hezbollah had built division-sized, well-equipped forces over a decade, enabling them to shift from routine operations to full combat within six hours. He described the lack of a pre-emptive strike as a key factor behind the initial catastrophe.
Aloni criticized the current war aims, saying political leaders are reluctant to adjust objectives during the conflict. He argued that dismantling Hamas without a diplomatic plan for governance in Gaza leaves a power vacuum, and that eliminating Hamas as a social movement is unrealistic. He suggested the primary goal should be to prevent a repeat of October 7 by degrading Hamas's military capacity and strengthening border defences.
Both officers highlighted the difficulty of dealing with Hezbollah in Lebanon, noting that the Lebanese army lacks the capability to confront the group and that regional powers are unlikely to intervene directly. They described Israel's recent operations in Lebanon, such as the capture of the Beaufort fortress, as having limited strategic impact.
Regarding Iran, Hazoot said that while Israel achieved tactical successes in operations like Rising Lion and Epic Fury, it failed to neutralise Iran's nuclear programme, leaving a significant amount of enriched uranium intact. He warned that this poses a long-term security risk.
The interview also touched on Israel's relationship with the United States. Both speakers said Israel continues to rely on American support but must also develop independent diplomatic and economic capacities. They noted shifting U.S. public opinion and the need for Israel to demonstrate its value as a partner in regional security.
Aloni and Hazoot concluded that future Israeli security policy should focus on maintaining flexible, achievable objectives, improving ground-force readiness, and preparing for rapid responses to surprise attacks.