Grant Morrison Criticizes Green Lantern Series Finale as Morally and Legally Incoherent

Comic author Grant Morrison, who previously wrote Green Lantern for DC, said the finale of HBO’s "Lanterns" ends in a "morally and legally incoherent" way. In a newsletter response to reader questions, Morrison acknowledged that the series works as a show because of the chemistry between leads Kyle Chandler and the supporting cast, but he took issue with the resolution of the plot.

He noted that the episode reveals Sheriff Kerry, played by Kelly Macdonald, as Hal Jordan’s killer, yet the narrative allows her to walk free after John Stewart intervenes. Morrison wrote, "> I didn’t really like the ending, although it was all neatly put together, and it’s hard to accept that everyone seemed fine with that psychotic break."

Morrison argued the lack of consequences undermines the premise of the Green Lantern Corps as an intergalactic law-enforcement body, questioning why the Guardians would accept operatives being murdered without repercussions. He also criticized the decision to let John Stewart release the Manhunter, a potentially world-destroying figure, without accountability.

The writer contrasted his view with comments from series co-creator Tom King, who suggested the killer’s circumstances might justify leniency. Morrison responded that such reasoning would not hold up in a court of law.

Despite his criticisms, Morrison left open the possibility of a second season, speculating that a revived Hal Jordan as Parallax could provide a new direction. He noted rumors of renewal after the finale attracted 10.5 million viewers, though HBO executives have previously indicated no development plans.