Cornell student who tipped police on alleged fraternity rape says case was mishandled
A student who provided leads to campus police about a 2024 gang-rape allegation at the Chi Phi fraternity says the investigation was poorly managed, prompting calls for an independent review.
A Cornell University student who anonymously shared information with campus police about a reported gang rape at the Chi Phi fraternity said she feels the case was not properly handled. The student said she first heard rumors of the assault within two days of the alleged incident on Oct. 19-20 and later saw a Snapchat group message mentioning "free p----" in the frat house, which prompted her to contact police.
She told investigators she provided details about fraternity members’ messages, possible witnesses and alleged drug use, describing the interview as "fairly competent" and lasting about half an hour. After the university issued a crime-safety alert, the student said many peers assumed the police report would lead to a thorough investigation, but she now feels "betrayed" by the process.
University President Michael I. Kotlikoff called the allegations "deeply disturbing" and said an independent review by an outside law firm will examine Cornell’s handling of the case. Police records show multiple witness interviews and anonymous tips were not forwarded to the Tompkins County District Attorney. District Attorney Matthew Van Houten later concluded the allegations did not merit charges, citing insufficient criminal evidence, though he has agreed to reopen the inquiry after the state attorney general was appointed as special prosecutor.
The fraternity was suspended and later expelled by its national organization, which said it would take steps to protect community safety. Two of the men named in the lawsuit were removed from the university’s rugby team, and the team issued a statement expressing distress over the allegations. Several sorority members described campus reactions ranging from support for the victim to confusion and criticism of the university’s response.
Cornell previously said a month-long Title IX investigation resulted in expulsions and suspensions for some of the accused. The case continues to draw scrutiny from students, university officials and state authorities.