Wisconsin judge lifts temporary seal on Josh Jacobs case, cites victim privacy rules
Brown County Circuit Judge Marc Hammer ended a temporary seal on records in Green Bay Packers running back Josh Jacobs' domestic-violence case, noting that a public-record request process must still consider the victim's privacy rights.
Brown County Circuit Judge Marc Hammer lifted a temporary seal on Thursday for the court files in the domestic-violence case involving Green Bay Packers running back Josh Jacobs. The unsealed records include video that police say shows Jacobs throwing his ex-girlfriend to the ground, an incident for which he pleaded no contest to misdemeanor battery and criminal damage to property.
The judge emphasized that Wisconsin’s constitution grants crime victims rights to dignity, respect and privacy. He warned that any release of the video must follow the state’s public-record law and undergo a balancing test by the custodial police agency, which will weigh public interest against potential harm to the victim.
The victim had asked the court to permanently seal the video, arguing that disclosure would jeopardize her privacy, dignity, personal security and emotional wellbeing, invoking the state’s Marsy’s Law protections. Hammer denied the request on procedural grounds, stating that a permanent seal order should be pursued through a public-record request rather than a court order.
The temporary seal expires on Friday, after which any individual may submit a public-records request to Hobart/Lawrence police. The agency must conduct the required balancing test, notify both the victim and Jacobs of its decision, and allow either party to appeal the outcome in court.
Hammer noted that his decision was informed by guidelines from the state attorney general and affirmed that the court and local authorities will uphold victims’ privacy rights as mandated by the state constitution. He also instructed law enforcement to treat prior denied requests as closed, with new requests to be evaluated starting Friday.