Commanders quarterback Jayden Daniels faces treatment decision after second elbow dislocation
Washington quarterback Jayden Daniels suffered a second left elbow dislocation and must choose between surgery that would end his season or non-surgical rehabilitation, according to orthopedic specialists.
Washington Commanders quarterback Jayden Daniels dislocated his left elbow for a second time during a game against the Dallas Cowboys on Sept. 20. The repeat injury has prompted orthopedic surgeons to advise the 2024 Offensive Rookie of the Year on whether to undergo surgery, which would likely end his season, or to pursue a non-surgical rehabilitation plan similar to last year.
“He’s going to have some tough choices to make,” said Dr. David Litner of Houston Methodist Hospital.
X-rays showed no bone fractures, classifying the dislocation as “simple,” a type that usually does not require surgery. However, ligament damage can leave the joint unstable, according to Dr. Litner. Dr. Laith Jazrawi, an elbow specialist at NYU Langone, noted that doctors are evaluating whether surgery could restore stability.
The injury occurred when Daniels fell backward and landed with his arm in a supinated position, a mechanism described by Dr. Francis Alberta of Hackensack Meridian as textbook for elbow dislocations. While recurrence of such injuries in athletes is rare, Alberta said the low rate underscores the unusual nature of Daniels’ case.
Jazrawi said the quarterback was cleared to play without a brace, but the current assessment will focus on the extent of ligament and capsule damage. Because the injury involves Daniels’ non-throwing arm, the treatment options differ from a similar injury on his throwing side.
“Thank God,” Jazrawi added, noting that a non-throwing arm injury allows for different management strategies.
Former NFL quarterback and analyst Kurt Warner suggested Daniels could attempt to play through the injury, as he did in 2007, but specialists warned that the mechanism that caused the dislocation could recur.
The decision will weigh medical risk, Daniels’ pain tolerance, and his confidence in returning to play. Options include strengthening surrounding muscles, using a brace, or scheduling surgery either now or after the season. Litner emphasized that the situation is more complex than a clear-cut injury like an ACL tear.