Historical market trends suggest strong third-year performance after upcoming midterms
Data shows the S&P 500 has historically posted its highest annual gains in the year following a midterm election, a pattern that could influence expectations for the market in 2027.
Voters will cast ballots on Nov. 3 in the midterm elections that will determine the composition of Congress during President Trump’s second term. Prediction markets currently favor Democrats to win a majority.
Analysis by Opening Bell Daily indicates that, since 1950, the calendar year after a midterm election – the third year of a presidential cycle – has delivered the strongest average gain for the S&P 500, with a 17.2% increase. By comparison, the first year of a term averaged 8.4%, the midterm year itself 4.6%, and the election year 8.1%.
Using the SPDR S&P 500 ETF Trust (SPY) as a proxy, the index has risen 16.35% so far in 2025, slightly below the historical third-year average. As of Oct. 27, SPY was up 12.83% for the year, with two months remaining.
Historical patterns also show that the S&P 500 has risen in the 12 months after every midterm election since 1950, averaging a 15.1% gain. Research cited by Yahoo Finance notes a similar average one-year post-midterm return of 14.4%.
However, the sample size is limited and outcomes vary. Only 11 of the 19 midterm years since 1950 ended higher, and those years experienced an average peak-to-trough decline of 17.5%, compared with 11.2%-13.3% in other years. The market this year has already seen a 9.1% decline from its peak through Oct. 16.
Morgan Stanley strategists observed that the composition of the congressional majority may influence equity markets more than the party affiliation of the winning side. Current conditions include a 10-year Treasury yield around 5.00%, University of Michigan consumer sentiment at 48.1, and a VIX index near 18.4.
Analysts caution that while historical cycles suggest a potential boost for the market in 2027, actual returns will depend on earnings, interest rates, and valuations. Investors are advised to maintain a long-term strategy and monitor election results, the resulting congressional balance, and interest-rate trends.