Silver prices slip as ETFs see redemptions and bond yields rise
Silver fell amid weaker industrial demand, investor redemptions from ETFs and higher bond yields, prompting analysts to advise staggered buying and modest portfolio allocations.
Silver prices have dropped as both industrial and investment demand weakened, with several global silver ETFs recording redemptions, a fund manager said anonymously. The pullback in investment demand is linked to rising bond yields, which make non-income-producing assets like silver less attractive.
"As long as we are talking about higher interest rates and higher inflation, the fall could be capped," said Manav Modi, analyst at Motilal Oswal Financial Services.
Analysts note that the Federal Reserve is expected to keep rates elevated, and a hawkish stance could keep investors focused on U.S. Treasuries. Tapan Patel, commodities fund manager at Tata Mutual Fund, said the Fed’s December policy decision will shape the metal’s outlook.
Satish Dondapati of Kotak Mutual Fund added that silver’s sensitivity to economic conditions may cause near-term volatility, given its dual reliance on industrial use and investment demand. While the metal remains in a supply deficit, ETF redemptions have temporarily eased the shortage, and the deficit is projected to persist into next year.
Copper production, a major source of silver as a by-product, is expected to run into surplus by 2027, according to the International Copper Study Group, which could further pressure silver prices unless copper supply tightens.
Despite the recent correction, silver ETFs are up roughly 20% over the past year, and the metal has outperformed gold in recent years. About two-thirds of silver output is consumed industrially, leaving a limited free float for coins, bars and ETFs.
Analysts recommend investors adopt a staggered buying approach rather than lump-sum purchases, keeping silver’s allocation smaller than gold’s due to its higher volatility.
"Silver is very high beta. Overall precious metals can be up to 10-15% of the portfolio, split roughly 70:30 between gold and silver. Investors may accumulate silver gradually for the long term, but it should be held for diversification, not as a return enhancer," said Patel.
"Avoid lump-sum investments and consider staggered buying on corrections. Given its higher volatility compared to gold, conservative investors should keep a smaller allocation to silver within a diversified portfolio," said Dondapati.