Big Ten falters in nonconference play as individual performances draw attention in Week 2
The Big Ten recorded a 3-6 record against Power-4 opponents, while standout performances by players such as Drew Mestemaker and Arch Manning highlighted the week’s action.
The Big Ten finished its second week of the season with a 3-6 record against Power-4 opponents, trailing the SEC (8-2) and the ACC (5-6). Two of the conference’s traditionally strong programs, Ohio State and Oregon, suffered defeats, and other Big Ten teams also struggled in nonconference matchups.
SEC coach Nick Saban argued on a sports talk show that the conference has greater depth than the Big Ten, noting that the latter relies on only a few top teams. The statement was echoed by the week’s results, which saw Ohio State lose to Texas and Oregon fall to Oklahoma State.
Texas rallied from a 20-point deficit to beat top-ranked Ohio State 24-23, with Arch Manning leading a fourth-quarter comeback. Oklahoma State ended a 21-game FBS losing streak by upsetting sixth-ranked Oregon 39-31, highlighted by quarterback Drew Mestemaker’s 10-yard touchdown run that gave him a strong showing for NFL scouts.
"It’s not like the Big Ten where there’s three good teams at the top and then nothing," Saban said on the program.
Mestemaker, a former walk-on at North Texas, threw for 317 yards and two touchdowns while rushing for 109 yards, outperforming Oregon’s Dante Moore, who was previously projected as the top quarterback prospect for the 2027 NFL Draft.
Quarterback play remained inconsistent for other teams. Michigan’s Bryce Underwood contributed a 38-yard touchdown run but completed only nine passes for 111 yards, while Oklahoma’s John Mateer threw for 189 yards, a touchdown and an interception that set up Michigan’s winning score.
Defensive units generated an unusually high number of interception returns for touchdowns, with 19 pick-six plays recorded across FBS games, nearly double the weekly average since 2019.
In the Group of Six playoff race, Boise State rallied from a 14-point deficit to defeat Memphis 38-20, keeping the competition for the non-Power-4 automatic bid open. Other Group of Six teams such as Tulsa, New Mexico, James Madison and Western Michigan posted early wins.
Outside of on-field action, Senator Ted Cruz appeared on a college football broadcast to promote legislation aimed at limiting transfers and eligibility, drawing boos from the crowd.
Overall, the week highlighted the Big Ten’s challenges against top-tier opponents, while individual performances and defensive highlights provided notable storylines.