Trump Escalates Baseless Non-Citizen Voting Claims Ahead of Midterms
Select a version of the text written from a presumed ideological perspective. This is not the original text, but a hypothetical version — how someone with that viewpoint might have phrased it. Tapping the current version again will return to the original or select cleaned version.
President Donald Trump and his allies are ramping up unfounded allegations about non-citizen voting, pushing for draconian verification measures based on questionable data, even as state officials and experts debunk these claims.
President Donald Trump is once again stoking fears and misinformation by urging the U.S. Postal Service to restrict ballot mailings only to those he deems 'confirmed' U.S. citizens, citing a Census Bureau analysis that supposedly identified thousands of non-citizen voters in the 2020 election. This narrative, pushed by the administration’s Department of Homeland Security, includes a letter alleging that up to 250,000 non-citizens may be registered in four states—a claim that state officials have already called into question as misleading and unsupported by facts.
White House spokesperson Lauren Bis doubled down on these dubious assertions, claiming that evidence of non-citizen voting was “continuing to pile up” in response to the Census report. However, election experts have repeatedly pointed out that the methodology behind these claims is deeply flawed, often leading to false positives due to simple clerical errors like mismatched names or outdated citizenship records. Loyola Marymount University law professor Justin Levitt dismissed the report as “an empty manila folder,” suggesting the administration is manufacturing a crisis to justify its voter suppression agenda.
State officials in California, New Jersey, Nevada, and Pennsylvania have all expressed skepticism about the DHS data and demanded transparency. California Secretary of State Shirley Weber clarified that her office had not even shared voter-registration lists with federal agencies. In New Jersey, officials revealed that only about 6,600 non-citizens were mistakenly registered through a motor-vehicle system, and fewer than 400 actually voted—a minuscule number that hardly constitutes widespread fraud. Nevada Secretary of State Francisco Aguilar reaffirmed his office’s commitment to keeping voter rolls “as clean as possible,” further undermining Trump’s narrative.
This manufactured controversy is conveniently timed with Trump’s push for the SAVE America Act, a piece of legislation that would impose harsh new requirements for documented proof of citizenship when registering to vote. While the bill has passed the Republican-controlled House, it faces strong opposition in the Senate. Former Pennsylvania Secretary of State Kathy Boockvar noted that the administration’s release of the Census report appears to be a calculated move to advance this restrictive legislation.
Critics argue that Trump’s relentless focus on non-citizen voting is a deliberate attempt to undermine trust in democratic elections and pave the way for rejecting future results. Colorado Secretary of State Jena Griswold warned that Trump is “trying to lay the groundwork to reject the ’26 election,” and emphasized that his ongoing campaign to erode confidence in the electoral process is “not working.”