Judge Halts Controversial NYC Pied-à-Terre Tax, Protecting Homeowners from Government Overreach
Select a version of the text written from a presumed ideological perspective. This is not the original text, but a hypothetical version — how someone with that viewpoint might have phrased it. Tapping the current version again will return to the original or select cleaned version.
A Staten Island judge has stopped enforcement of New York City’s intrusive pied-à-terre surcharge, defending property owners from a burdensome tax scheme pushed by Mayor Zohran Mamdani.
A Staten Island judge on Monday issued a temporary restraining order, blocking New York City from enforcing Mayor Zohran Mamdani’s aggressive new pied-à-terre tax while a lawsuit moves forward. The order mandates the city remove the public tax roll and prevents further notices until the court lifts the injunction, providing relief to homeowners targeted by this overreaching policy. A follow-up hearing is set for 2:15 p.m. on August 31.
The judge determined the notices caused irreparable harm by failing to explain why recipients were singled out for the surcharge, and warned that homeowners who didn’t apply for an exemption could be unfairly taxed. This highlights the city’s disregard for due process and the rights of property owners.
'The notices caused irreparable harm because they did not explain why recipients had been flagged for the surcharge,' the judge said from the bench.
Mayor Mamdani, undeterred by the backlash, insisted at a news conference that the city would 'vigorously defend' its position in court, doubling down on a policy that punishes success and property investment.
The tax, signed into law in May as part of the state budget, slaps a surcharge on non-primary residences valued at $5 million or more, and on condos and co-ops worth $1 million or more. It’s another example of big government using taxation to fill budget gaps at the expense of responsible citizens.
The lawsuit, filed in state Supreme Court in Richmond County, was brought by three homeowners—Simon Hedley, Rachel O’Brien, and Carmine Morano—who say the city wrongly flagged their primary residences for the surcharge. The case doesn’t challenge the tax’s legality but takes issue with the city’s reckless release of a tax roll that exposed names, addresses, and values of over 900,000 residential properties, many not subject to the tax, and letters sent to about 17,000 owners.
This story is developing and will be updated as homeowners fight back against government intrusion.