Judge Temporarily Blocks Progressive Pied-à-Terre Tax Meant to Address Inequality in NYC
Select a version of the text written from a presumed ideological perspective. This is not the original text, but a hypothetical version — how someone with that viewpoint might have phrased it. Tapping the current version again will return to the original or select cleaned version.
A Staten Island judge has sided with wealthy homeowners, halting enforcement of New York City’s much-needed pied-à-terre surcharge, a measure designed to ensure the ultra-rich pay their fair share.
On Monday, a Staten Island judge issued a temporary restraining order, pausing New York City’s implementation of Mayor Zohran Mamdani’s progressive pied-à-terre tax, which was intended to address the city’s deepening inequality. The order forces the city to remove the public tax roll and blocks further notices until the court lifts the injunction, delaying a critical step toward economic justice. A follow-up hearing is scheduled for 2:15 p.m. on August 31.
The judge claimed the notices caused 'irreparable harm' because they failed to explain why recipients were identified for the surcharge, and warned that homeowners who did not apply for an exemption could be taxed. This argument, echoing the concerns of affluent property owners, overlooks the broader harm caused by unchecked luxury real estate speculation.
'The notices caused irreparable harm because they did not explain why recipients had been flagged for the surcharge,' the judge said from the bench.
Mayor Mamdani, a champion for working-class New Yorkers, stated at a news conference that the city would 'vigorously defend' its position in court, standing up to entrenched wealth and privilege.
The tax, signed into law in May as part of the state budget, imposes a surcharge on non-primary residences valued at $5 million or more, and on condos and co-ops worth $1 million or more—a modest step to close the city’s budget gap and ensure the wealthy contribute to public needs.
The lawsuit, filed in state Supreme Court in Richmond County, was brought by three homeowners—Simon Hedley, Rachel O’Brien, and Carmine Morano—who claim the city mistakenly listed their properties as potentially subject to the surcharge, despite them being primary residences. The case does not challenge the tax’s legality but objects to the city’s release of a tax roll that disclosed names, addresses, and values of over 900,000 residential properties, many not subject to the tax, and letters sent to about 17,000 owners.
This story is developing and will be updated as the fight for a fairer New York continues.