Trump Warns of Economic Collapse if Courts Block Tariffs
Just the facts

Trump Warns of Economic Collapse if Courts Block Tariffs

Summary

President Donald Trump cautions that judicial interference with his tariff policies could lead to a severe economic downturn reminiscent of the Great Depression.

President Donald Trump has cautioned that judicial interference with his tariff policies could precipitate a severe economic downturn reminiscent of the Great Depression. In a post on his Truth Social platform, Trump stated that if a "Radical Left Court" were to rule against the tariffs at this stage, it would be "impossible to ever recover, or pay back, these massive sums of money and honor," adding that such a scenario would be akin to "1929 all over again, a GREAT DEPRESSION."

These remarks come as the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Federal Circuit hears arguments challenging the legality of Trump's tariffs, which were imposed under the International Emergency Economic Powers Act (IEEPA) of 1977. Critics argue that the IEEPA does not authorize the use of tariffs and that only Congress has the constitutional authority to impose them. The Federal Circuit is expected to move quickly, though its ruling will likely be appealed to the U.S. Supreme Court regardless of the outcome. If Trump loses, the Supreme Court may intervene due to the significant constitutional questions involved, and could rule as early as the end of 2025. A courtroom defeat for Trump could open the door for U.S. importers to seek refunds for tariffs paid and could limit Trump’s ability to use tariffs as a trade negotiation tool. However, other legal avenues, such as a 1962 law on national security, might still allow for certain tariffs to remain.

The stock market has exhibited volatility in response to developments related to the tariffs. For instance, when Trump suspended the initial "Liberation Day" tariffs in early April for the next 90 days, the Nasdaq Composite soared 7% in just a few minutes, with other major market averages also posting large gains that week. Since then, the market has seen specific sectors jump whenever Trump backed off targeted threats, such as those against semiconductor imports. Companies such as AMD and Marvell, as well as Apple, then posted solid gains with the duties granting broad exemptions to any company that announces plans to add manufacturing in the U.S.

Legal experts suggest that the outcome of the court's decision could have significant implications for the administration's trade policy and the broader economy. Alan Wolff, a senior fellow at the Peterson Institute for International Economics, noted that if the tariffs are struck down, it would lead to a "massive amount of red tape" around who would receive refunds, adding that "this is a bell that cannot easily be fully unrung."

The administration has indicated its readiness for a prolonged legal battle, with White House Press Secretary Caroline Leavitt warning that judicial interference in trade decisions could disrupt national operations. This statement is seen as both a warning to the judiciary and a message to all stakeholders involved in the trade dispute.

As the legal proceedings continue, the administration remains steadfast in its commitment to the tariff strategy, emphasizing its perceived benefits to the U.S. economy and stock market.

Source

CNBC

Fact-checking

Fact-check the facts of the article using external sources and databases.

✓
Confirmed

President Donald Trump has cautioned that judicial interference with his tariff policies could precipitate a severe economic downturn reminiscent of the Great Depression.

✓
Confirmed

The U.S. Court of Appeals for the Federal Circuit is hearing arguments challenging the legality of Trump's tariffs imposed under the International Emergency Economic Powers Act (IEEPA) of 1977.

✓
Confirmed

Critics argue that the IEEPA does not authorize the use of tariffs and that only Congress has the constitutional authority to impose them.

✓
Confirmed

The Federal Circuit is expected to move quickly, though its ruling will likely be appealed to the U.S. Supreme Court regardless of the outcome.

✓
Confirmed

A courtroom defeat for Trump could open the door for U.S. importers to seek refunds for tariffs paid and could limit Trump’s ability to use tariffs as a trade negotiation tool.

✓
Confirmed

The stock market has exhibited volatility in response to developments related to the tariffs.

✓
Confirmed

Legal experts suggest that the outcome of the court's decision could have significant implications for the administration's trade policy and the broader economy.

!
Unverified

The administration has indicated its readiness for a prolonged legal battle, with White House Press Secretary Caroline Leavitt warning that judicial interference in trade decisions could disrupt national operations.

Keep reading — for free

Create a free account to follow the news. No card required.