US officials allege Chinese firm Moonshot copied Anthropic's model, experts question feasibility
White House science adviser Michael Kratsios claimed Moonshot replicated Anthropic’s Fable LLM using prohibited chips, but AI researchers say the timeline and technical hurdles make such distillation unlikely.
White House science adviser Michael Kratsios said Moonshot, the Chinese company behind the open-weight Kimi K3 model, built its system by copying Anthropic’s Fable LLM and by using export-restricted chips. He described the alleged large-scale, covert industrial distillation as “unacceptable” and linked it to broader discussions about banning Chinese open-weight models.
Kratsios’ statement echoed Treasury Secretary Scott Bessent’s comment that watermarks from U.S. models have been found in many Chinese systems, though the Treasury did not detail what those watermarks are. Moonshot did not respond to inquiries about its training methods, and Kratsios provided no further evidence.
AI experts expressed doubt that simple distillation could explain Kimi K3’s capabilities. Braden Hancock of the Laude Institute said the timeline is implausible, noting that Fable was publicly released only on July 1 and that “you can’t distill that much data, train a model, and release it in two weeks.” Nathan Lambert of the Allen Institute for AI added that as models approach the frontier, distillation becomes less effective and that “if it were the case, everyone would be easily able to catch up…but we have not.”
Distillation involves querying a target model to generate data for post-training, often followed by supervised fine-tuning (SFT). Lambert argued that SFT’s impact diminishes as models grow more complex, and that achieving Fable-like performance would likely require reinforcement learning, which demands substantial computational resources and time.
Anthropic previously accused Moonshot and other Chinese firms of systematically extracting capabilities from its models, citing millions of anomalous queries identified through IP addresses and metadata. Anthropic did not comment on the specific claim of Fable distillation.
The practice of model distillation is not limited to China; Elon Musk testified that SpaceX AI used it to develop its Grok model, indicating industry-wide use. Hancock noted that Moonshot’s founders include a former Carnegie Mellon PhD student, emphasizing the technical expertise of Chinese teams.
Separately, Kratsios mentioned that Moonshot allegedly accessed Nvidia Grace Blackwell 300 chips and GB300-equipped servers, hardware banned from export to China. Georgetown researcher Sam Bresnick highlighted the need for “know your customer” regulations for data-center hardware to prevent illicit use.
“If you are letting a company conduct huge training runs on your state-of-the-art hardware, there needs to be a reporting mechanism for who that company is and what they’re doing,” Bresnick said.