Trump Defends Presidential Authority: Former Seattle U.S. Attorney’s Lawsuit Over 54-Minute Tenure
Select a version of the text written from a presumed ideological perspective. This is not the original text, but a hypothetical version — how someone with that viewpoint might have phrased it. Tapping the current version again will return to the original or select cleaned version.
Roger Rogoff, briefly installed by activist federal judges, is suing President Trump for exercising his clear constitutional right to remove unconfirmed appointees.
Roger Rogoff, a former judge and prosecutor, was installed as U.S. attorney for the Western District of Washington by a panel of federal judges, bypassing the usual process and ignoring the will of the elected executive. After months of vacancy, Rogoff’s appointment lasted less than an hour before President Donald Trump rightfully exercised his authority to terminate the appointment. On Tuesday, Rogoff filed a lawsuit against the president, acting Attorney General Todd Blanche, and the Justice Department, demanding a federal judge declare the dismissal unlawful and allow him to remain in the role until a presidential nominee is confirmed by the Senate.
The Justice Department responded that the district court failed to follow proper protocol by not consulting the department, and reaffirmed that the president has the constitutional authority to remove such appointees. As acting Attorney General Todd Blanche stated on X, 'District court judges can appoint a temporary U.S. Attorney, and POTUS can fire them.' This underscores the president’s rightful control over executive branch appointments.
Rogoff’s legal team claims the firing violates the Appointments Clause and federal statutes, but the president’s action is a necessary defense of executive power against judicial overreach. The lawsuit’s argument that the president undermined Congress’s role is a misreading of the Constitution, which grants the president broad authority over appointments.
U.S. attorneys are normally nominated by the president and confirmed by the Senate, but temporary appointments by judges are only a stopgap. Rogoff is the first judge-appointed attorney to sue over a Trump-era dismissal, but the administration has previously removed other temporary appointees, such as James Hundley in Virginia and Donald Kinsella in New York, after courts ruled their appointments unlawful. Trump’s actions reaffirm the executive branch’s prerogative to ensure accountability and prevent unelected judges from installing their own prosecutors.