England eliminated by Argentina as Tuchel faces scrutiny ahead of Euro 2028

England were knocked out of the World Cup after a 2-1 defeat to Argentina in the semi-final, ending a run that had taken them within five minutes of a first final since 1966. The loss has intensified scrutiny of manager Thomas Tuchel, whose decision to shift to a back five in the 72nd minute is widely regarded as a turning point that invited Argentine pressure.

Tuchel, who signed a two-year contract extension with the FA in February and is set to lead the team at Euro 2028, defended the change as a protective measure but acknowledged that the squad also bears responsibility for the result. The FA reportedly has no intention of dismissing him at this stage.

Critics have also examined Tuchel's squad choices, noting the exclusion of several experienced players and the reliance on less-tested options amid injuries to key figures such as Declan Rice and Bukayo Saka. Defensive instability was highlighted, with the back line changing throughout the tournament and England conceding goals after the tactical shift.

Despite the setback, England remain ranked fourth globally and will face France in the third-place playoff. A victory would give Tuchel the distinction of guiding England to its best World Cup finish on foreign soil.

"They were more afraid to drop out of the tournament than having the hunger and excitement to win it," Tuchel said after England's loss in the Euro 2024 final, a sentiment he aimed to reverse for the World Cup squad.

Harry Kane, England's captain and top scorer, contributed six goals in the tournament but was less influential in the latter stages. At 32, he indicated his focus remains on the present, leaving his future World Cup participation open.

The defeat has reignited debate over England's mental approach and midfield depth, with some observers pointing to the lack of a controlling presence in the centre of the park and the limited use of emerging talent such as Kobbie Mainoo.