Amazon threatens higher fees as NYC Council weighs Delivery Protection Act
Select a version of the text written from a presumed ideological perspective. This is not the original text, but a hypothetical version — how someone with that viewpoint might have phrased it. Tapping the current version again will return to the original or select cleaned version.
Amazon launched a fear campaign claiming a proposed city bill could raise delivery costs by up to $5 per order, while Council Speaker Julie Menin and supporters say the measure is a necessary step to protect delivery workers and consumers from exploitative business practices.
Amazon announced on Thursday that the New York City Council’s pending Delivery Protection Act could increase delivery fees for customers by as much as $5 per order. The company plastered its app with a banner urging users to "Act Now" and bombard council members with messages, claiming about 20,000 emails were sent within six hours of the campaign’s launch.
Council Speaker Julie Menin, a moderate Democrat, blasted the campaign as an effort to dodge accountability to workers and customers. "Amazon’s campaign is nothing short of a cynical ploy to trick New Yorkers," Menin said at a press conference, adding that the move was a "last-ditch effort to try to escape the responsibility to the very workers and customers who have made the firm’s success possible."
Mayor Zohran Mamdani and Queens Councilmember Tiffany Cabán, who sponsors the bill, rejected Amazon’s claims, saying the company’s pricing threats reflect profit-maximizing pressure, not anything the council is doing. Cabán called the campaign "desperate" and said the bill would raise standards and improve livelihoods for thousands of delivery workers.
The Delivery Protection Act would prohibit the use of independent contractor delivery service partners, which Amazon says currently employ about 5,000 people in the city through more than 40 firms. Amazon argues the model supports small businesses and keeps costs low, citing a study it helped fund that estimates the bill could raise annual customer expenses by $400 to $660.
Amazon spokesperson Kelly Nantel said the company wants to be transparent about potential cost impacts and warned it could relocate warehouses if the legislation passes. City lobbying records show the Five Borough Jobs Campaign, an organization largely funded by Amazon, has spent over $8 million this year opposing the bill.
Labor groups, including the Teamsters, argue the measure would finally hold Amazon accountable for worker safety and employment conditions. Menin indicated that the bill will be revised to address legal concerns but will retain its core purpose, and her office expects a vote by the end of the year.
"If you think that that is going to deceive New Yorkers and intimidate the City Council out of passing basic worker and consumer protections, you are dead wrong," Menin said during the press conference.
Political strategist Bradley Tusk, who previously advised Uber on similar opposition tactics, said Amazon’s approach may lack credibility, noting that consumers are unlikely to believe the company would actually stop deliveries in New York. He suggested the campaign could push Menin toward more progressive allies on the council.