Leaders of China, United States and Russia hold historic trilateral summit in Shenzhen
Left

Leaders of China, United States and Russia hold historic trilateral summit in Shenzhen

Select a version of the text written from a presumed ideological perspective. This is not the original text, but a hypothetical version — how someone with that viewpoint might have phrased it. Tapping the current version again will return to the original or select cleaned version.

Summary

China’s Xi Jinping, U.S. President Donald Trump and Russia’s Vladimir Putin met on the sidelines of APEC in a highly choreographed summit that produced broad statements on nuclear risks, energy and UN reform, while critics said the gathering was heavy on symbolism and light on enforceable commitments.

China, the United States and Russia held a 90-minute trilateral summit on November 19 at a lakeside resort in Shenzhen during the APEC meeting. The three presidents issued a joint declaration that promised more dialogue on nuclear risks, cooperation on refined petroleum supplies and a discussion of United Nations reform, but it did not establish specific timelines, enforcement tools or mechanisms for future meetings.

Analysts said each leader tried to claim a diplomatic win from the carefully staged encounter. Wang Dan, China director at Eurasia Group, called the summit a “diplomatic win for China” that boosted Beijing’s image as the host of rival powers. She also said the gathering let President Trump project a strong global leadership image at home and put nuclear arms control back on the agenda, though she questioned how substantive the nuclear discussion really was. Wang said “the biggest winner is Russia,” noting that President Putin secured a separate 40-minute pull-aside with Trump and described the talks as “open” and “very useful,” while pushing for the format to continue.

The declaration repeated the familiar line that “a nuclear war cannot be won and must never be fought” and pledged ongoing dialogue on non-proliferation, but it stopped well short of any arms-control cuts or formal three-way negotiations. Wu Xinbo, dean of Fudan University’s Institute of International Studies, said the outcome matched China’s view that the United States and Russia should first make substantial nuclear reductions before China could be expected to follow. Daniel Salisbury, senior fellow at the International Institute for Strategic Studies, called the commitment to nuclear-security talks “significant and positive” because there have been no ongoing arms-control discussions since the expiration of New START.

The leaders also discussed conflicts in Ukraine, the Middle East, the Korean Peninsula and broader proliferation issues. Xi urged the three powers to respect each other’s core interests and avoid challenging red lines, while Putin said cooperation could strengthen global stability. Trump described the meeting as “bigger than Yalta.” Chong Ja Ian, associate professor at the National University of Singapore, warned that the sweeping agenda and repeated emphasis on the three powers suggest an attempt to claim a privileged role in managing world affairs, potentially implying a division of influence among Beijing, Moscow and Washington.

The joint declaration included an energy pledge to increase production and supply of refined petroleum products, though it gave no details on quantities or timelines. Wang Dan noted the pledge could have positive spill-over effects for global markets. Chinese Foreign Minister Wang Yi later said China believes “all countries, big or small, are equal” and that major powers should lead in promoting equality, credibility and cooperation.

Observers said the summit’s broad principles will be hard to translate into concrete actions without clear mechanisms. The declaration did not establish regular high-level exchanges or crisis-prevention channels, leaving the next steps uncertain.

Source

CNA

Keep reading — for free

Create a free account to follow the news. No card required.