Aid groups give Trump Gaza peace plan a low score amid worsening humanitarian crisis
Just the facts

Aid groups give Trump Gaza peace plan a low score amid worsening humanitarian crisis

Summary

Five major international aid organisations say the Trump administration's Gaza peace plan has failed to ensure humanitarian access and civilian protection, as Israeli forces expand control and aid deliveries remain limited.

A coalition of five leading international aid organisations has released a humanitarian scorecard that rates the United Nations-backed Gaza peace plan, drafted by the Trump administration, at four out of 26 points. The plan received zero points for humanitarian access and only one point for civilian protection.

The scorecard notes that Israeli forces have moved the “Yellow Line” further west, increasing control of Gaza from about 58 % at the start of the cease-fire to roughly 65 % today, according to the UN Office for the Coordination of Humanitarian Affairs (OCHA). Israeli officials claim control of 70 % of the territory. The advance has confined around 2.1 million Palestinians to an area of about 128 sq km, equating to roughly 16,000 people per square kilometre; recent mapping puts the confined area at 109 sq km, or nearly 19,300 people per square kilometre.

"Palestinians in Gaza are being confined as the ‘Yellow Line’ expands. This is displacement by design, and a ceasefire that allows it is a ceasefire in name only," said Lilu Thapa, executive director for the Middle East, Asia and Europe at the Danish Refugee Council.

Since the cease-fire was declared in October, at least 1,650 Palestinians have been killed and 5,975 wounded. Shaun Hughes, country director for the World Food Programme in Palestine, said the situation feels far from a cease-fire, with Israeli control limiting food production, prohibiting fishing and driving unemployment above 80 %.

The Board of Peace and International Stabilization Force, created by President Donald Trump, has been criticised for lacking Palestinian representation and for providing political cover for Israel’s actions. Ramy Abdu, founder of the Euro-Mediterranean Human Rights Monitor, described the board as a “political shield for genocide and starvation.”

Humanitarian aid deliveries have fallen short of the plan’s promise of 600 UN-coordinated trucks per day; in September an average of 49 such trucks entered Gaza, only two percent of which carried medical supplies. Commercial trucks have been allowed to bring food and non-essential items, while essential hygiene and shelter goods remain scarce due to “dual-use” restrictions.

The winter season has intensified the shelter crisis, with donors pledging about $18 billion but reconstruction still pending. Flooding from a recent storm damaged more than 70,000 tents, leading to several deaths, while tens of thousands of tents and blankets await entry into Gaza.

International officials have called for greater pressure on Israel and other UN Security Council members to meet their obligations, and for legal accountability through international courts and national jurisdictions.

Keep reading — for free

Create a free account to follow the news. No card required.