Labour MP calls for new online safety legislation after Google declines to remove Russell Brand prison video
Jess Phillips said the government lacks authority to force platforms to delete distressing content and suggested a second online safety act may be required following Google's refusal to take down a YouTube video featuring Russell Brand's message from prison.
Labour MP Jess Phillips said a new online safety law may be needed after Google declined a UK government request to remove a YouTube video in which Russell Brand’s wife relayed his claim of innocence from prison. The video, posted days after Brand’s conviction for sexual offences, has attracted close to 850,000 views.
The Ministry of Justice opened an inquiry into whether the broadcast violated prison rules, but Google, which owns YouTube, said it was reviewing the content and noted that Brand’s channel had been suspended from the YouTube partner programme since September 2023, preventing monetisation.
Phillips, a former minister for safeguarding, told BBC Radio 4’s Today programme that existing Ofcom codes are voluntary and do not give the government power to compel removal of such material. She said, "Regulatory frameworks, changes and potentially a second online safety act is needed, because before we haven’t had prisoners who had massive YouTube followings."
She added that pressure on companies like Google would continue, stating that leaving the video up shows the current codes are insufficient.
Minister for Children and Families Josh MacAlister urged Google to follow Meta’s precedent of disabling Brand’s accounts for breaching community-harm standards. Housing minister Matthew Pennycook described the video as disturbing and expressed concern for victims seeing it.
Conservative leader Kemi Badenoch cautioned against immediate demands for private platforms to remove content without clear legal breaches, noting that YouTube is a private service.
The 2023 Online Safety Act, which aims to protect users from illegal and age-inappropriate content, does not specifically address prisoners using social media to communicate externally. Phillips said the Brand case highlights a gap that may require legislative amendment.