Defense lawyer calls case against former RAAF pilot one of the weakest ever
Just the facts

Defense lawyer calls case against former RAAF pilot one of the weakest ever

Summary

In his closing remarks, barrister Saul Holt argued that the evidence linking former pilot Robert John Crawford to his wife's death was insufficient and largely circumstantial.

Former Royal Australian Air Force pilot Robert John Crawford faced a murder trial after his wife Frances was found dead at their property west of Brisbane on July 30, 2024. The defence counsel, Saul Holt, KC, told jurors that the prosecution’s case was "one of the weakest circumstantial cases you will ever see in a criminal court" and urged them to consider whether the evidence proved beyond reasonable doubt that Crawford strangled his wife.

Holt reiterated his opening argument that the prosecution was presenting a narrative rather than factual proof, describing the portrayal of Crawford as a "cartoon character" and emphasizing that personal history, including admitted infidelities, was not evidence of murder. He highlighted inconsistencies such as the claim that the death was staged, questioning how a drag mark could be faked.

The defence also referenced a text message sent by Frances at 11:21 p.m. on the night of the incident, in which she asked Crawford about the lawnmower, and his reply, "give me a sec," suggesting the mower had not been moved by him. Holt concluded by asking jurors to determine whether the prosecution had met the legal standard of proof, noting that the evidence did not conclusively rule out a lawnmower accident.

The jury had previously viewed graphic photographs of the scene, including blood stains and grass around the overturned mower, as part of the evidence presented during the trial.

Keep reading — for free

Create a free account to follow the news. No card required.