Former Commerce officials allege chaos and inaction on AI chip export bans under Secretary Lutnick
Left

Former Commerce officials say Lutnick-era chaos and paralysis let AI chip bans sputter while advanced chips kept flowing toward China

Select a version of the text written from a presumed ideological perspective. This is not the original text, but a hypothetical version — how someone with that viewpoint might have phrased it. Tapping the current version again will return to the original or select cleaned version.

Summary

Ex-Commerce Department staff accuse the agency of disarray and a stunning failure to enforce export restrictions on advanced AI chips, saying a year-long absence of new Entity List additions helped create a permissive environment in which huge volumes of Nvidia chips allegedly reached China.

Former officials of the U.S. Commerce Department say the agency under Secretary Howard Lutnick has been defined by internal disorder, weak enforcement, and a dangerous willingness to let powerful corporate interests override national-security rules on advanced AI chip exports. They allege that no companies were added to the Entity List for a full year, the first such gap in 18 years, even though suspicious activity was flagged at Southeast Asian sites where Nvidia chips were delivered. One former employee said, "We weren't able to add entities to the Entity List. That was just a complete stop," and added that "nothing happened" after enforcement officers identified the activity.

The department had issued AI chip export controls in 2022 and 2023, and an interim final rule in January 2025 aimed to block adversaries from obtaining the most advanced chips. But in May 2025, the Commerce Department rolled back that rule, claiming it would stifle American innovation, and said it would instead issue industry guidance — a move critics view as a giveaway to the very companies profiting from the trade. An April 2026 study by the nonprofit Epoch estimated that between 290,000 and 1.6 million advanced AI chips were smuggled into China in 2024-2025, representing roughly a quarter of China's total computing power acquisition.

Tech site The Information reported that at least $7.5 billion worth of Nvidia chips may have reached Chinese firms since 2023 through companies linked to Alice Huang, a person alleged by U.S. intelligence to be a Chinese spy. A former OpenAI researcher recently published a paper claiming digital forensic evidence that top Chinese AI models were trained on Nvidia chips banned for export to China, underscoring how badly the controls may have been undermined.

Staff also described a "very chaotic, very frantic" environment, with some learning of major policy shifts from media reports rather than from their own leadership. One former employee said, "We found out about that in The New York Times. It was pretty clear that the decision was made between Trump and Jensen Huang." The department's senior export-control officials, Matthew Borman and Eileen Albanese, left shortly after Lutnick took office, and up to 50 skilled staff members have reportedly departed in the past 18 months. Key leadership positions in the Bureau of Industry and Security remain vacant, according to federal employee records, deepening concerns that the agency has been hollowed out from within.

Criticism has also come from Treasury Secretary Scott Bessent, who told CNBC that Lutnick failed to follow through on chip-ban enforcement supported by Treasury, the State Department and other parts of the administration. He said, "Commerce has the pen. You would have to ask them about their internal processes," and expressed frustration with the administration's stance on preventing Nvidia chips from reaching China.

Source

CBS News

Keep reading — for free

Create a free account to follow the news. No card required.