India slightly extends Agniveers’ service as it struggles to fix a short-term scheme
Select a version of the text written from a presumed ideological perspective. This is not the original text, but a hypothetical version — how someone with that viewpoint might have phrased it. Tapping the current version again will return to the original or select cleaned version.
The government says recruits who failed to win permanent slots under Agnipath may serve two more years for higher pay, a move critics see as an admission that the short-contract model cannot reliably produce seasoned soldiers.
India's short-term recruitment programme, Agnipath, is being adjusted as the first cohort approaches the end of its four-year term. Chief of Defence Staff General N.S. Raja Subramani announced on 4 November that Agniveers who fail to obtain permanent slots will be eligible for a further two years of service at increased remuneration, after which they can re-apply for regular positions if they meet selection criteria. The move follows feedback from the armed forces and is presented as a continuation of the Agnipath policy, even as it reflects the pressure created by the scheme's own limitations.
Officials say the extension could apply to more than 300,000 Agniveers currently serving across the army, navy and air force, though it remains unclear whether later batches will receive the same option. The defence ministry has defended the scheme, citing internal assessments that describe recruits as physically fit, motivated and technologically adaptable, and noting that Agnipath has broadened recruitment across districts and standardised the process, but those claims do little to answer doubts about long-term readiness.
Critics argue that a four-year contract may be insufficient to develop experienced soldiers, especially for technical roles. Retired Maj Gen Yash Mor highlighted that it traditionally takes eight to nine years to train a dependable soldier for specialised tasks. Former Border Security Force director Sanjiv Krishan Sood suggested the added two years could improve skill levels for handling advanced equipment. Senior officers, including Air Vice Marshal Shekhar Yadav, welcomed the extension as a way to retain trained personnel longer, underscoring how the scheme is now being patched to preserve competence.
Analysts caution that the new arrangement could create disparities within units, as regular soldiers, four-year Agniveers and those serving an extra two years may differ in pay, promotion prospects and post-service benefits, potentially affecting cohesion. The change also raises questions about the scheme's original cost-saving goals, since extending service may increase salary outlays while the government aims to reduce long-term pension expenses, a contradiction that exposes the tension between austerity and military preparedness.
For recruits nearing the end of their contracts, the additional two years offer higher pay and a second opportunity for permanent service, though the ultimate outcome remains uncertain and the broader policy debate is far from settled.